Roy's View From... Loan Update

[Slim Man]

I think Marsh has probably found his level. Looked lost against Blackburn, and hasn't particularly been that impressive when playing in other games for us. My grandad who's a Rotherham fan has said he's really liked Buyabu so far, hopefully continues his form and comes back better for it

No he hasn't. He's fucking great

 

[SwissBlade]

Yes, but give him games and he will improve. Can you say the same about Ayew? At least Marsh has a sell on value

Yes, I agree, Marsh needs games in a team he can be competitive in, which i guess that's why he's gone to Chesterfield now.

Ayew that just played in the world cup, you mean?

 

[CopenhagenBlade]

Yes, I agree, Marsh needs games in a team he can be competitive in, which i guess that's why he's gone to Chesterfield now.

Ayew that just played in the world cup, you mean?

Yes he played in the World Cup…not sure your point

 

[SwissBlade]

Yes he played in the World Cup…not sure your point

I wasn't sure in the relevance of him being brought into a conversation about Marsh. I don't see Marsh being out on loan being connected to Ayew. The loan is about Marsh's development towards first team football with United or as you say, being sold on with a future value

Marsh isn't ready and won't get game time. So it made complete sense that he was sent on loan and its great to see he's doing well so far

 

[CopenhagenBlade]

I wasn't sure in the relevance of him being brought into a conversation about Marsh. I don't see Marsh being out on loan being connected to Ayew. The loan is about Marsh's development towards first team football with United or as you say, being sold on with a future value

Marsh isn't ready and won't get game time. So it made complete sense that he was sent on loan and its great to see he's doing well so far

Ayew is an aged player, who has offered very little at his previous club, won’t improve, won’t see his value increase and has little or no loyalty to the club.
Marsh plays in a similar position and is the complete opposite of all the points raised about Ayew. He might prove to be not good enough at this level but Ayew proved that last year…despite him going to the World Cup.
I know who I’d rather see coming on for the last 20 minutes of a game

 

[Champagneblade]

In fairness he played away at Blackburn (i think) in the cup and looked way off the pace.

Having him out on loan at Chesterfield seems the best for all parties at this time

He played left wing.

He’s not and never has been a left winger.

Bit unfair to judge a lad when, with limited experience, he’s asked to “do a job” for the team.

 

[SwissBlade]

Ayew is an aged player, who has offered very little at his previous club, won’t improve, won’t see his value increase and has little or no loyalty to the club.
Marsh plays in a similar position and is the complete opposite of all the points raised about Ayew. He might prove to be not good enough at this level but Ayew proved that last year…despite him going to the World Cup.
I know who I’d rather see coming on for the last 20 minutes of a game

I think the two are entirely independent at this point.

Marsh clearly needed games in the lower tier to develop.
He simply wouldn't have made the bench other than to fill a position.

Now he's able to play regular football and get game time he wouldn't have had at the lane.

Maybe he comes back in Jan, like Arblaster did from Port Vale, but there is value in him playing regularly for Chesterfield

 

[Champagneblade]

Yes, I agree, Marsh needs games in a team he can be competitive in, which i guess that's why he's gone to Chesterfield now.

Ayew that just played in the world cup, you mean?

To be fair SwissBlade there are players in the Cape Verde and Curaçao squads that went to the World Cup too but wouldn’t get on the Kiveton team!

Like the old “he’s got experience of playing in Europe” when he’s turned out for some Latvian minnows that declared a National holiday when they didn’t get ten put past them!

 

[SwissBlade]

He played left wing.

He’s not and never has been a left winger.

Bit unfair to judge a lad when, with limited experience, he’s asked to “do a job” for the team.

I think it reinforces the point .

 

[CopenhagenBlade]

I think the two are entirely independent at this point.

Marsh clearly needed games in the lower tier to develop.
He simply wouldn't have made the bench other than to fill a position.

Now he's able to play regular football and get game time he wouldn't have had at the lane.

Maybe he comes back in Jan, like Arblaster did from Port Vale, but there is value in him playing regularly for Chesterfield

I do agree to some level, I would rather we took a loan from a Premier League club, someone who wants to impress than Ayew who just wants a pay day. Marsh needs games and good to see him getting those, and goals, with Chesterfield.
Only hope is that One gets game time when he is fit.

 

[tyke1889]

View attachment 244654
Hey Roygbiv the ads are back in full force. Maybe it's beacaue I'm in moose land. But it's honestly making me want to add your page to my ad block list.

Oy, you should click on that advert and give Roygbiv his 0.001p payment. He'll never get rich off the backs of us Blades with people like you!
(And me cos I use Brave browser )

 

[Roygbiv]

Oy, you should click on that advert and give Roygbiv his 0.001p payment. He'll never get rich off the backs of us Blades with people like you!
(And me cos I use Brave browser )

It is fucking annoying in fairness. I have to admit I only look at the site properly when someone flags up an issue so I appreciate the heads up.

I know how unreadable a website can be with too many ads. I've read The Star

 

[dexter101]

I know how unreadable a website can be with too many ads. I've read The Star

You are a long way off that level!

 

[tyke1889]

You are a long way off that level!

Might be a better journalist though.

 

[dexter101]

Might be a better journalist though.

no might about that! might start a "get Roygbiv onto Panorama team" petition. Open up the world of transfer dealings...

 

[SwissBlade]

I do agree to some level, I would rather we took a loan from a Premier League club, someone who wants to impress than Ayew who just wants a pay day. Marsh needs games and good to see him getting those, and goals, with Chesterfield.
Only hope is that One gets game time when he is fit.

I don't think its about Ayew or another loanee, its an entirely independent point after you decide whether he's ready or not for the first team. The reality, in my view, is that he's not ready. So the option is keep him in the dev squad and stick him on the bench when were desperate, unlikely to even get off the bench, or send him on loan.

Loaning out players isn't always the answer, but i think for Marsh it was.

 

[SE1Blade]

I do agree to some level, I would rather we took a loan from a Premier League club, someone who wants to impress than Ayew who just wants a pay day. Marsh needs games and good to see him getting those, and goals, with Chesterfield.
Only hope is that One gets game time when he is fit.

A Premier League loan will be expensive and will need to play regularly.
Ayew is a “last 15 minuter” that we needed so to not leave us short but won’t be a regular starter.
I don’t expect much from him but I don’t see who else we could have got in the circumstances.

 

[Balham]

In fairness he played away at Blackburn (i think) in the cup and looked way off the pace.

Having him out on loan at Chesterfield seems the best for all parties at this time

We played Marsh, who’s a #10/centre forward, at left midfield against Blackburn. It’s not surprising he looked a bit lost because it’s a completely different role. Says a lot about the manager that he even asked Marsh to do that.

There is no place for Marsh in the current Jurassic 4-4-fucking-2. He’s better off at Chestervegas.

 

[FINUK]

Watched buyabu at Rotherham today - blowing out his arse after 20 min and the 2/3 times he got ball one on one with full back he passed backwards with no intention of attacking - forget this one not worth it

 

[Berkshire Blade]

Marsh scored again. Perhaps we need to loan him to league one clubs... because it seems he's good enough for league 2!

 

[Nick Jansky]

Marsh scored again. Perhaps we need to loan him to league one clubs... because it seems he's good enough for league 2!

He’s standing out in L2. And impressed in the SPL. Good enough for L1.

 

[VictoryBlade]

I do agree to some level, I would rather we took a loan from a Premier League club, someone who wants to impress than Ayew who just wants a pay day. Marsh needs games and good to see him getting those, and goals, with Chesterfield.
Only hope is that One gets game time when he is fit.

Under Wilder he won't!

 

[Broomhall Blade]

Watched buyabu at Rotherham today - blowing out his arse after 20 min and the 2/3 times he got ball one on one with full back he passed backwards with no intention of attacking - forget this one not worth it

Blowing out of arse after 20min
Passing Backwards
Wilder "Thats my Boy"

 

[Broomhall Blade]

Marsh scored again. Perhaps we need to loan him to league one clubs... because it seems he's good enough for league 2!

I'm guessing no League1 club wanted him.

 

[Nedski]

It is fucking annoying in fairness. I have to admit I only look at the site properly when someone flags up an issue so I appreciate the heads up.

I know how unreadable a website can be with too many ads. I've read The Star

Could you perhaps turn it in to a podcast?

You could then do the accents for each club while also making each individual view sound like a different person. I think we'd all LOVE to hear this.

 

[Berkshire Blade]

I'm guessing no League1 club wanted him.

Most likely. This might have changed...bit like how mcgoldrick amazingly dropped down to league 2 before other clubs woke up

 

[I should coco]

It is fucking annoying in fairness. I have to admit I only look at the site properly when someone flags up an issue so I appreciate the heads up.

I know how unreadable a website can be with too many ads. I've read The Star

Don't apologise mate.

You provide a cracking service for nothing, so if there;s a few ads, we just have to suck it up.

Some of our entitled wankers, apply their football watching far too widely.

Keep up the good work and igniore the moaners.

 

[FenBlade]

I was at Cambridge v Wimbledon today. Sam Curtis not in Cambridge’s match-day squad. They played 3-4-3. Curtis was already in competition with established favourite right back Liam Bennett. Hard to see how he gets many games. Seems an odd loan move for him.

 

[Berkshire Blade]

Zatterstrom not playing is quite a funny bit now. He's got to be one of the highest paid footballers per minutes on the pitch and it's not even like he's injured or banned!

 

[Carlton Blade]

I think the two are entirely independent at this point.

Marsh clearly needed games in the lower tier to develop.
He simply wouldn't have made the bench other than to fill a position.

Now he's able to play regular football and get game time he wouldn't have had at the lane.

Maybe he comes back in Jan, like Arblaster did from Port Vale, but there is value in him playing regularly for Chesterfield

As much as I would rather have Marsh in the squad than Ayew, I read this and nodded along