Player Suggestion Will Smallbone

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?


CaptainMorgans said:
Out of interest, how did you interpret it?
Click to expand...
I don't read too much into anything hecky says

Why you forensically disect it add bits on and then portray that narrative as fact astounds me

You may well be right but no one has stated hecky had to be told no ,yet its been repeated on here as fact several times as often happens on here opinion becomes fact and history is rewritten
 
Well to be fair, PH himself did say he was disappointed that he wasn't allowed to keep ES and BS which tends to suggest that he would have liked to have kept them on. That would have been a mistake despite who made the final decision. The disappointment was that he mentioned that he wanted to keep them. If the board have overruled him (seems likely) then we owe them thanks for doing so and wanting to move on some of the seasoned pros. We would be having churn to the squad not having the same squad again. ES and BS had run their races with us and JF and BO can be thankful they have had the opportunity of a contract put their way.
 
Weasel said:
Well to be fair, PH himself did say he was disappointed that he wasn't allowed to keep ES and BS which tends to suggest that he would have liked to have kept them on. That would have been a mistake despite who made the final decision. The disappointment was that he mentioned that he wanted to keep them. If the board have overruled him (seems likely) then we owe them thanks for doing so and wanting to move on some of the seasoned pros. We would be having churn to the squad not having the same squad again. ES and BS had run their races with us and JF and BO can be thankful they have had the opportunity of a contract put their way.
Click to expand...
He never mentioned being allowed or not allowed to keep anyone
 
Frank the tank said:
I don't read too much into anything hecky says

Why you forensically disect it add bits on and then portray that narrative as fact astounds me

You may well be right but no one has stated hecky had to be told no ,yet its been repeated on here as fact several times as often happens on here opinion becomes fact and history is rewritten
Click to expand...

"Everyone knows I wanted to keep the squad together... I'm disappointed but sometimes things are out of your control. What we lose with losing Enda and Billy is the thing that I've been trying to protect and that's the character about the group of players...

I also know we're going to be working within the budget we've been given and the more players you have to replace within that budget the harder it gets, so from that end I'm disappointed."

I'm not really sure you're onto something with this one Frank the tank .
Think he made it as obvious as he possibly could that he wanted to keep him but was denied.

If it wasn't within his control, who's control was it within?
He wanted to keep them but whomever has that control above him went against his wishes...
 
CaptainMorgans said:
"Everyone knows I wanted to keep the squad together... I'm disappointed but sometimes things are out of your control. What we lose with losing Enda and Billy is the thing that I've been trying to protect and that's the character about the group of players...

I also know we're going to be working within the budget we've been given and the more players you have to replace within that budget the harder it gets, so from that end I'm disappointed."

I'm not really sure you're onto something with this one Frank the tank .
Think he made it as obvious as he possibly could that he wanted to keep him but was denied.

If it wasn't within his control, who's control was it within?
He wanted to keep them but whomever has that control above him went against his wishes...
Click to expand...
So things being out of your control can only mean heckingbottom was over ruled and heckingbottom saying what he did can only mean that he fought to keep them and was told to fuck off ?

There are no other possibilities at all that could apply to those quotes or that scenario ?

Just that one extremely negative one that with heckys track record is probably 50 / 50 wether it's actually even true or not

Couldn't be that sharp and enda wanted the same premier league contracts they had before even though they were unlikely to play and were offered less and decided to leave ?
Or that hecky actually wanted them out but doesn't want to be seen to go against club legends ?

But no it can only be interpreted in one way
You're way and funnily enough that would be the one that has the most negative connotations
 
CaptainMorgans said:
"Everyone knows I wanted to keep the squad together... I'm disappointed but sometimes things are out of your control. What we lose with losing Enda and Billy is the thing that I've been trying to protect and that's the character about the group of players...

I also know we're going to be working within the budget we've been given and the more players you have to replace within that budget the harder it gets, so from that end I'm disappointed."

I'm not really sure you're onto something with this one Frank the tank .
Think he made it as obvious as he possibly could that he wanted to keep him but was denied.

If it wasn't within his control, who's control was it within?
He wanted to keep them but whomever has that control above him went against his wishes...
Click to expand...
Maybe it was within the control of the budget? Maybe he has to face up to bringing in less players but of a higher quality and adding their wages into the pot helps with that.

I don't doubt that Billy and Enda are good influences. But you'd have to be negatively inclined to immediately write off what new players may bring. Perhaps they bring someone in who is uber professional and takes the club to new levels.

For me, I'm doing my best to be in the wait and see camp. When we kick off in less than 2 months, we'll have an idea how well we recruited. I don't see a 33 year old left back and a 37 year old striker impacting that though.
 
Champagneblade said:
Maybe it was within the control of the budget? Maybe he has to face up to bringing in less players but of a higher quality and adding their wages into the pot helps with that.

I don't doubt that Billy and Enda are good influences. But you'd have to be negatively inclined to immediately write off what new players may bring. Perhaps they bring someone in who is uber professional and takes the club to new levels.

For me, I'm doing my best to be in the wait and see camp. When we kick off in less than 2 months, we'll have an idea how well we recruited. I don't see a 33 year old left back and a 37 year old striker impacting that though.
Click to expand...
Reading the whole thing in context it's pretty obvious he is saying there are pros and cons to every move and releasing them means losing two strong characters ,weakening the group and having to find two more players to fill the squad

The interpretation that he has fought to keep them and was told no is something that's just not there
He won't have been told we'll thanks for the input Paul but we think no they're gone
 
Frank the tank said:
So things being out of your control can only mean heckingbottom was over ruled and heckingbottom saying what he did can only mean that he fought to keep them and was told to fuck off ?

There are no other possibilities at all that could apply to those quotes or that scenario ?

Just that one extremely negative one that with heckys track record is probably 50 / 50 wether it's actually even true or not

Couldn't be that sharp and enda wanted the same premier league contracts they had before even though they were unlikely to play and were offered less and decided to leave ?
Or that hecky actually wanted them out but doesn't want to be seen to go against club legends ?

But no it can only be interpreted in one way
You're way and funnily enough that would be the one that has the most negative connotations
Click to expand...

I think you're clutching at straws but it's fine to have differing opinions.
 
CaptainMorgans said:
I think you're clutching at straws but it's fine to have differing opinions.
Click to expand...
It's all about differing opinions yet mine is clutching at straws and yours is being presented as fact even though you don't know it to be true ?
 
Frank the tank said:
He won't have been told we'll thanks for the input Paul but we think no they're gone
Click to expand...

I see. So you included in the conversations then to be so sure of this then?

Fine have you opinion and you are entitled to it. Mine is that it's fairly clear he wa told that some of the older players needed to be moved on to free up budget for others which are needed. So maybe he wasn't told 'x and y have to go' but 'resdibg between the lines' I think it's safe to assume he was told that some had to go. For the record I also wasnt involved in those conversations either.
 
Weasel said:
I see. So you included in the conversations then to be so sure of this then?

Fine have you opinion and you are entitled to it. Mine is that it's fairly clear he wa told that some of the older players needed to be moved on to free up budget for others which are needed. So maybe he wasn't told 'x and y have to go' but 'resdibg between the lines' I think it's safe to assume he was told that some had to go. For the record I also wasnt involved in those conversations either.
Click to expand...
My whole fucking point is that no one on this forum was included in any of the conversations
Everything else is conjecture
 
Frank the tank said:
My whole fucking point is that no one on this forum was included in any of the conversations
Everything else is conjecture
Click to expand...

But are you trying to make a point or a fucking point? It does makes a difference.

If it was you trying to make a point, I think you could have a point, but if you are trying to make a fucking point, then I don't think you have a fucking point at all. Conjecture you see.
 

Frank the tank said:
Your earlier post was fucking stupid
Click to expand...

Conjecture. I thought I had a point to be fair. Or maybe it was a 'fucking point'? Clearly not. A poster as distinguished as your good self saw through it all and has seen it for what it was i.e. 'fucking stupid'. You are clearly an intellectual fella. So we'll leave it there. Still think you don't have a 'fucking point' though. Stupid or not.
 
Mouth of the South said:
Agree but would needing to replace those two on top of replacing the Man City lads as well as Sharp, Stevens and JOC mean the rebuilding job over summer is too big resulting in starting next season with very little of the team that earned promotion?
The thought of Fleck, Robinson and particularly Osborn playing regularly next season, given that offers were made and appear to still be on the table, is worrying. I would have hope Paul Mitchell would have at least have had decent replacements for those identified.
Click to expand...
Hecki can say what he wants ! Just words mean nothing
The3 who are going were not going to get contracts if promoted.
Championship would be different and the experience of Sharp and Enda would have Been usefull playing regularly or not.As it stands now we have 3 spaces ! there wages will come in handy for a loan player possibly two.






.











O
 
Some reyt sandy vaginas on here at the minute, August needs to hurry up.
 
andy m said:
Some reyt sandy vaginas on here at the minute, August needs to hurry up.
Click to expand...

Relax. Sit back and enjoy the summer. Football will have its chance in the Autumn. I enjoy talking about United in the summer but I certainly don't miss watching them. I have other things in my life that take precedence.
 
CaptainMorgans said:
Out of interest, how did you interpret it?
Click to expand...
I interpreted it as having been given a budget which meant that he had a choice to make over bringing in a certain number of new players or keeping on the old guard whereas he would have liked to be able to do both, hence his disappointment.

But that’s just my interpretation, as is yours, and it might be that neither of us is right.
 
Nick Jansky said:
I interpreted it as having been given a budget which meant that he had a choice to make over bringing in a certain number of new players or keeping on the old guard whereas he would have liked to be able to do both, hence his disappointment.

But that’s just my interpretation, as is yours, and it might be that neither of us is right.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure our opinion differs greatly based on what you just said...
Either way, everyone entitled to their own opinions per previous post.
 
Started against Wednesday tonight. Extremely impressive passing stats and involvement

Screenshot_20230804-221751_Sofascore.jpg

No chance he goes anywhere now. Predictable this would happen
 
Hamandcheese said:
Started against Wednesday tonight. Extremely impressive passing stats and involvement

View attachment 167206

No chance he goes anywhere now. Predictable this would happen
Click to expand...

Predictable what would happen? A player weren’t interested in had a decent enough game in the division below where we’re currently at? I reckon that might happen a lot this season
 
Didn’t think he looked all that, they were literally walking round for large parts of the game.

They struggled to create much or gain any type of momentum.

Not a game to judge anyone on.
 
ben1987 said:
Didn’t think he looked all that, they were literally walking round for large parts of the game.

They struggled to create much or gain any type of momentum.

Not a game to judge anyone on.
Click to expand...
Southampton were an example of a team without creative players. No penitration against a team parking the bus.
 
ben1987 said:
Didn’t think he looked all that, they were literally walking round for large parts of the game.

They struggled to create much or gain any type of momentum.

Not a game to judge anyone on.
Click to expand...
They played a poor team off the park for most the match without showing what they really can do, easy win but should have attacked them more really, just showed they will be in top 2 from the off really?
 
Thought Stuart Armstrong looked decent when he came on down the left, although he turned us down during the Wilder era
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

mattbianco1
Player Suggestion EFL Targets for 2025/26
2
Replies
40
Views
3K
ancientblade
A
bongleblade
Player Suggestion Mika Biereth
Replies
4
Views
1K
Blacksea
B
Nicolaus_Copernicus
Player Suggestion Luciano Valente - Groningen
Replies
3
Views
675
Aston max
Aston max
Nicolaus_Copernicus
Player Suggestion Aaron Zehnter
Replies
0
Views
444
Nicolaus_Copernicus
Nicolaus_Copernicus
brownblade
Player Suggestion Keito Nakamura
Replies
6
Views
1K
TJB.
TJB.

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom