My take ...

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

pommpey

THE FUTURE ... AS IT USED TO BE
Joined
Dec 9, 2015
Messages
9,261
Reaction score
26,531
Location
South Coast
A point is a point and its not three given away. But even the most happier of clappers might concede that although we remain top of the league for tonight at least, one feels that the momentum gained in the game last Saturday was somewhat lost. We'd made some chin-stroking changes - dropping Anel to the bench for Bash, Flecky now joining the long term injured, no Khadra and McAtee coming in to get his first start and one would hope we'd get hold of Luton Town in our teeth and shake the fuckers in the way a terrier shakes a farmyard rat to break its spine and neck and kill it early.

But the first half was unimpressive to be honest. We didn't seem to have a system and were effectively bossed and bullied in areas of the pitch where we should have had more effect. Ex-Blade Luke Freeman, a seemingly past-it benchwarmer/treatment table wage stealer had a decent game and bossed our midfield almost single headedly showing flashes of skill and vision maybe we have lacked for too long. When Luton offered him a home when we released him I thought, 'good luck with that fucker'. Now he's in some sort of resurgence and found buckets of time to thread balls, make runs and put Sander Berge in the front row seats (fairly as well) and run off with the ball. Our midfield three could cope with him or his fellow midfielders.

Their goal was one bit avoidable but three bits bad marking. The replay shows Morris plonked firmly between Norwood and Basham and completely unchallenged, which if you are defending a cross from the zone is unforgivable. TO be able to leap and touch the ball like that and steer it into the net is a lesson of touch-tight-marking. I doubt Anel would have let him get away with that. Again, we are weak at defending the cross and again, we pay for it. It's notable - when opposition teams cross the ball into our six yard box there always seems to be a player or two who has bags of time to attack the ball and get it toward our goal yet when we cross it, the opposition penalty area is congested and packed and they (usually) deal with our ball easily.

Our midfield again today was the outcome of the result. In the first half, Berge couldn't find effective ways forward and didn't like being pressed and robbed and McAtee looked well over his head in a man's game. Norwood didn't do too badly but he again was sometimes profligate so without those options and settled pattern of play, our impetus was on McBurnie and NDaiye who at times looked on a hiding to nothing despite a lot of effort. McBurnie's goal was deserved and very, very welcome, but the post-equaliser ten minutes were not capitalised upon and we did spend a lot of time tentatively defending Luton's breaks whilst offering nothing much in return.

Foderingham 6/10: Decent game with a good, if pointless, save. Hope he recovers quickly.
Baldock 7/10: Enjoyed his performance and unlucky to be booked. I would like him to cut in diagonally at times and head toward goal, Bogle-style. Some decent defensive interventions
Basham 6/10: Sometimes a shaky return and other times consummate and composed with some decent defensive headers. Should have been a lot tighter marking for their goal, however
Egan 6.5/10: Once again marshalled the defence well when needed and put in his usual dogged spirit but he doesn't like the old ball over the top, does he?
RND 5/10: He works hard does Rhys, but I maintain - he's NOT a Centre Back. His shortcomings and tactical nous in effectively defending are made up by liability-wresting and 'mixing it up' which is okay when you are Chris Morgan or Virgil Van Dyk. He defends as a CB like he's playing LWB still and tonight he was bullied to fuck
Lowe 5.5/10: A quiet, practically vanilla game for him. Didn't see him in advanced positions much which told me all I need to know about his game and the fact that tonight he played like a flat-four LB rather than a marauding LWB in a 3-5-2
Berge 5.5/10: Thought he was outplayed and outmuscled most of the game, and vanished for long periods, even more so after taking a seat in the stands
Norwood 7/10: Another improved performance even if error prone at times. Good efforts on goal
McAtee 2/10: Very poor and our weak link in that first half. There were too many periods where he was outran, showed poor control, shite distribution and looking like an academy player blooded too early. Let's not get too bone hard on the hype on this lad, or we'll be back in Woodburn territory. If he is that magical, we need to see it materialise, because tonight, he was pretty dogwazz.
NDaiye 7/10: Again a great, grafting outing where he is the only point to deliver to and goes and gets it at all costs. We got another 15 out of him tonight as well which was good
McBurnie 7/10: Drops a whole mark for me because although we have a new McBurnie in the team now, the old one comes through like a stubborn skidmark. Just wish he'd get on with the game and stop the shithousery (the diving, the wrestling, the arms-up-appealing-to-the-ref because, as we have seen, he lurks in the shallows and can give us that bite we need. Fucking epic goal from him and deserved celebrations. Thank fuck he is off the mark now and hopefully ... there's more to come.

Doyle 6/10: A considerable upgrade on McAteer. Much more endeavour however not a great deal to show for it
Amissah 7/10: Giant of a keeper and looks commanding, taking his first cross with ease and producing a quality stop late on from Jerome
Anel 6/10: Looked a lot more solid with him at the back
Brewster 6/10: Still underfed and reliant on digging out his own chances. Scuffer of a shot late on, one of three for us

As said, a point is a point and all that. But we lack at times that 'gets you out of your seat' capability and spend a lot of time either doggedly defending or simply passing it about like in a practice match. Again, the midfield is guilty of not carrying it up the pitch and doing what MGW used to do with aplomb, namely put them on a the back foot and afraid to tackle. Khadra was (I believed) the answer to this but tonight he wasn't anywhere near the squad. Without that capability and potential on the pitch we will see a lot of games like this one tonight.

pommpey

First

pommpey
 
Last edited:

A point is a point and its not three given away. But even the most happier of clapper might concede that although we remain top of the league for tonight at least, one feels that the momentum gained in the game last Saturday was somewhat lost. We'd made some chin-stroking changes - dropping Anel to the bench for Bash, Flecky now joining the long term injured, no Khadra and McAtee coming in to get his first start and one would hope we'd get hold of Luton Town in our teeth and shake the fuckers in the way a terrier shakes a farmyard rat to break its spine and neck and kill it early.

But the first half was unimpressive to be honest. We didn't seem to have a system and were effectively bossed and bullied in areas of the pitch where we should have had more effect. Ex-Blade Luke Freeman, a seemingly past-it benchwarmer/treatment table wage stealer had a decent game and bossed our midfield almost single headedly showing flashes of skill and vision maybe we have lacked for too long. When Luton offered him a home when we released him I thought, 'good luck with that fucker'. Now he's in some sort of resurgence and found buckets of time to thread balls, make runs and put Sander Berge in the front row seats (fairly as well) and run off with the ball. Our midfield three could cope with him or his fellow midfielders.

Their goal was one bit avoidable but three bits bad marking. The replay shows Morris plonked firmly between Norwood and Basham and completely unchallenged, which if you are defending a cross from the zone is unforgivable. TO be able to leap and touch the ball like that and steer it into the net is a lesson of touch-tight-marking. I doubt Anel would have let him get away with that. Again, we are weak at defending the cross and again, we pay for it. It's notable - when opposition teams cross the ball into our six yard box there always seems to be a player or two who has bags of time to attack the ball and get it toward our goal yet when we cross it, the opposition penalty area is congested and packed and they (usually) deal with our ball easily.

Our midfield again today was the outcome of the result. In the first half, Berge couldn't find effective ways forward and didn't like being pressed and robbed and McAtee looked well over his head in a man's game. Norwood didn't do too badly but he again was sometimes profligate so without those options and settled pattern of play, our impetus was on McBurnie and NDaiye who at times looked on a hiding to nothing despite a lot of effort. McBurnie's goal was deserved and very, very welcome, but the post-equaliser ten minutes were not capitalised upon and we did spend a lot of time tentatively defending Luton's breaks whilst offering nothing much in return.

Foderingham 6/10: Decent game with a good, if pointless, save. Hope he recovers quickly.
Baldock 7/10: Enjoyed his performance and unlucky to be booked. I would like him to cut in diagonally at times and head toward goal, Bogle-style. Some decent defensive interventions
Basham 6/10: Sometimes a shaky return and other times consummate and composed with some decent defensive headers. Should have been a lot tighter marking for their goal, however
Egan 6.5/10: Once again marshalled the defence well when needed and put in his usual dogged spirit but he doesn't like the old ball over the top, does he?
RND 5/10: He works hard does Rhys, but I maintain - he's NOT a Centre Back. His shortcomings and tactical nous in effectively defending are made up by liability-wresting and 'mixing it up' which is okay when you are Chris Morgan or Virgil Van Dyk. He defends as a CB like he's playing LWB still and tonight he was bullied to fuck
Lowe 5.5/10: A quiet, practically vanilla game for him. Didn't see him in advanced positions much which told me all I need to know about his game and the fact that tonight he played like a flat-four LB rather than a marauding LWB in a 3-5-2
Berge 5.5/10: Thought he was outplayed and outmuscled most of the game, and vanished for long periods, even more so after taking a seat in the stands
Norwood 7/10: Another improved performance even if error prone at times. Good efforts on goal
McAtee 2/10: Very poor and our weak link in that first half. There were too many period where he was outran, showed poor control, shite distribution and looking like an academy player blooded too early. Let's not get too bone hard on the hype on this lad, or we'll be back in Woodburn territory. If he is that magical, we need to see it materialise, because tonight, he was pretty dogwazz.
NDaiye 7/10: Again a great, grafting outing where he is the only point to deliver to and goes and gets it at all costs. We got another 15 out of him tonight as well which was good
McBurnie 7/10: Drops a whole mark for me because although we have a new McBurnie in the team now, the old one comes through like a stubborn skidmark. Just wish he'd get on with the game and stop the shithousery (the diving, the wrestling, the arms-up-appealing-to-the-ref because, as we have seen, he lurks in the shallows and can give us that bite we need. Fucking epic goal from him and deserved celebrations. Thank fuck he is off the mark now and hopefully ... there's more to come.

Doyle 6/10: A considerable upgrade on McAteer. Much more endeavour however not a great deal to show for it
Amissah 7/10: Giant of a keeper and looks commanding, taking his first cross with ease and producing a quality stop late on from Jerome
Anel 6/10: Looked a lot more solid with him at the back
Brewster 6/10: Still underfed and reliant on digging out his own chances. Scuffer of a shot late on, one of three for us

As said, a point is a point and all that. But we lack at times that 'gets you out of your seat' capability and spend a lot of time either doggedly defending or simply passing it about like in a practice match. Again, the midfield is guilty of not carrying it up the pitch and doing what MGW used to do with aplomb, namely put them on a the back foot and afraid to tackle. Khadra was (I believed) the answer to this but tonight he wasn't anywhere near the squad. Without that capability and potential on the pitch we will see a lot of games like this one tonight.

pommpey

First

pommpey

First

pommpey
 
A point is a point and its not three given away. But even the most happier of clappers might concede that although we remain top of the league for tonight at least, one feels that the momentum gained in the game last Saturday was somewhat lost. We'd made some chin-stroking changes - dropping Anel to the bench for Bash, Flecky now joining the long term injured, no Khadra and McAtee coming in to get his first start and one would hope we'd get hold of Luton Town in our teeth and shake the fuckers in the way a terrier shakes a farmyard rat to break its spine and neck and kill it early.

But the first half was unimpressive to be honest. We didn't seem to have a system and were effectively bossed and bullied in areas of the pitch where we should have had more effect. Ex-Blade Luke Freeman, a seemingly past-it benchwarmer/treatment table wage stealer had a decent game and bossed our midfield almost single headedly showing flashes of skill and vision maybe we have lacked for too long. When Luton offered him a home when we released him I thought, 'good luck with that fucker'. Now he's in some sort of resurgence and found buckets of time to thread balls, make runs and put Sander Berge in the front row seats (fairly as well) and run off with the ball. Our midfield three could cope with him or his fellow midfielders.

Their goal was one bit avoidable but three bits bad marking. The replay shows Morris plonked firmly between Norwood and Basham and completely unchallenged, which if you are defending a cross from the zone is unforgivable. TO be able to leap and touch the ball like that and steer it into the net is a lesson of touch-tight-marking. I doubt Anel would have let him get away with that. Again, we are weak at defending the cross and again, we pay for it. It's notable - when opposition teams cross the ball into our six yard box there always seems to be a player or two who has bags of time to attack the ball and get it toward our goal yet when we cross it, the opposition penalty area is congested and packed and they (usually) deal with our ball easily.

Our midfield again today was the outcome of the result. In the first half, Berge couldn't find effective ways forward and didn't like being pressed and robbed and McAtee looked well over his head in a man's game. Norwood didn't do too badly but he again was sometimes profligate so without those options and settled pattern of play, our impetus was on McBurnie and NDaiye who at times looked on a hiding to nothing despite a lot of effort. McBurnie's goal was deserved and very, very welcome, but the post-equaliser ten minutes were not capitalised upon and we did spend a lot of time tentatively defending Luton's breaks whilst offering nothing much in return.

Foderingham 6/10: Decent game with a good, if pointless, save. Hope he recovers quickly.
Baldock 7/10: Enjoyed his performance and unlucky to be booked. I would like him to cut in diagonally at times and head toward goal, Bogle-style. Some decent defensive interventions
Basham 6/10: Sometimes a shaky return and other times consummate and composed with some decent defensive headers. Should have been a lot tighter marking for their goal, however
Egan 6.5/10: Once again marshalled the defence well when needed and put in his usual dogged spirit but he doesn't like the old ball over the top, does he?
RND 5/10: He works hard does Rhys, but I maintain - he's NOT a Centre Back. His shortcomings and tactical nous in effectively defending are made up by liability-wresting and 'mixing it up' which is okay when you are Chris Morgan or Virgil Van Dyk. He defends as a CB like he's playing LWB still and tonight he was bullied to fuck
Lowe 5.5/10: A quiet, practically vanilla game for him. Didn't see him in advanced positions much which told me all I need to know about his game and the fact that tonight he played like a flat-four LB rather than a marauding LWB in a 3-5-2
Berge 5.5/10: Thought he was outplayed and outmuscled most of the game, and vanished for long periods, even more so after taking a seat in the stands
Norwood 7/10: Another improved performance even if error prone at times. Good efforts on goal
McAtee 2/10: Very poor and our weak link in that first half. There were too many period where he was outran, showed poor control, shite distribution and looking like an academy player blooded too early. Let's not get too bone hard on the hype on this lad, or we'll be back in Woodburn territory. If he is that magical, we need to see it materialise, because tonight, he was pretty dogwazz.
NDaiye 7/10: Again a great, grafting outing where he is the only point to deliver to and goes and gets it at all costs. We got another 15 out of him tonight as well which was good
McBurnie 7/10: Drops a whole mark for me because although we have a new McBurnie in the team now, the old one comes through like a stubborn skidmark. Just wish he'd get on with the game and stop the shithousery (the diving, the wrestling, the arms-up-appealing-to-the-ref because, as we have seen, he lurks in the shallows and can give us that bite we need. Fucking epic goal from him and deserved celebrations. Thank fuck he is off the mark now and hopefully ... there's more to come.

Doyle 6/10: A considerable upgrade on McAteer. Much more endeavour however not a great deal to show for it
Amissah 7/10: Giant of a keeper and looks commanding, taking his first cross with ease and producing a quality stop late on from Jerome
Anel 6/10: Looked a lot more solid with him at the back
Brewster 6/10: Still underfed and reliant on digging out his own chances. Scuffer of a shot late on, one of three for us

As said, a point is a point and all that. But we lack at times that 'gets you out of your seat' capability and spend a lot of time either doggedly defending or simply passing it about like in a practice match. Again, the midfield is guilty of not carrying it up the pitch and doing what MGW used to do with aplomb, namely put them on a the back foot and afraid to tackle. Khadra was (I believed) the answer to this but tonight he wasn't anywhere near the squad. Without that capability and potential on the pitch we will see a lot of games like this one tonight.

pommpey

First

pommpey

Excellent .
 
I'm normally quite negative but I'm happy with that point. It was a fight from start to finish and most teams would have struggled for a point in a game that could have been mistaken for a local derby. Don't agree with the mcburnie comment either, it's hard to not get involved in a wrestling match when that's what their players were doing from minute one. He can't control getting fouled and it's not his fault refs refuse to clamp down on it.

It's rare a team can create a good football performance like we did against Blackburn and still stand up to the pure fight at a place like Luton. Still a work in progress but I'm positive after tonight.
 
Didn't see your mark for Hecky ?
Poor decision to select McAtee ahead of Doyle , versus thugs.
Poor decision to play Berge deep in first half - can't he see how this creates a gap between our mf & strikers ?
But I suppose he daren't risk McAtee as a defensive mf (body of a boy).
Even more reason to choose Doyle in these circs.
Poor not to hook McAtee immediately after crazy self-inflicted booking.
I still think he sets up too negatively away from home.
In 2nd half it was better with Doyle on but Berge didn't seize the initiative.

Hecky needs to get recruiting some assertive , muscular type as cover for defence/mf in these sorts of away games coz if we lose Doyle , we're gonna get physically bossed around.
 
It wasn't pretty but it could be a useful point. Plenty of teams will go there and succumb to pressure and leave empty handed.

It's just a pity for some of the players who are getting injured.

This would right now appear to have been an ideal opportunity for someone athletic like Coulibaly to emerge but he's crocked now too.

I don't see McAtee as a central midfielder. He'll be too much of a passenger without the ball. Perhaps as relief for N'Diaye at times before he learns the game a bit.

As you say, no point sugar coating it, he'll not look back on Luton away as a career highlight.

Fair play to McBurnie. I hadn't thought of the point you'd made about him. Less wrestling and appealing and more knocking around centre halves would be more appreciated.

I didn't think they let us settle. A little similar to how we went about Middlesborough last. Credit that we dug in. Could easily have been a place to go and come away with a frustrating narrow defeat.
 
RND
Rnd was bullied?

Not having that he gave as good as he got and I thought was decent all game.
RND is a great scrapper but he doesn't have the physique to deal with big strikers legally.
So he has his hands on them constantly.
Basically he is a yellow or red or penalty waiting to happen the whole game.
Tonight he was fortunate with a very lenient ref.
That said , the ref was such a homer that I was scared we'd get one sent off
 
Just got back an I think the point about Mcburnies shithousery is wrong he fought for every ball an was getting pulled and grappled evey time the ball came near him. We was bullied 1st half Macatee weak link like u say but 2nd we got to grips with them an Doyle looks very good, all in all a good point away from home at a ground and against a team that I do see many taking anything from. Oh an a mcburnie goal let's hope he kicks on now.
 
RND

RND is a great scrapper but he doesn't have the physique to deal with big strikers legally.
So he has his hands on them constantly.
Basically he is a yellow or red or penalty waiting to happen the whole game.
Tonight he was fortunate with a very lenient ref.
That said , the ref was such a homer that I was scared we'd get one sent off
Red was such a homer? As in homosexual? Can you explain what you mean fella?
 
Didn't see your mark for Hecky ?
Poor decision to select McAtee ahead of Doyle , versus thugs.
Poor decision to play Berge deep in first half - can't he see how this creates a gap between our mf & strikers ?
But I suppose he daren't risk McAtee as a defensive mf (body of a boy).
Even more reason to choose Doyle in these circs.

Poor not to hook McAtee immediately after crazy self-inflicted booking.
I still think he sets up too negatively away from home.
In 2nd half it was better with Doyle on but Berge didn't seize the initiative.

Hecky needs to get recruiting some assertive , muscular type as cover for defence/mf in these sorts of away games coz if we lose Doyle , we're gonna get physically bossed around.
You've posted much that I was going to. He got the selection wrong IMO, as per the bold above.
 

A point is a point and its not three given away. But even the most happier of clappers might concede that although we remain top of the league for tonight at least, one feels that the momentum gained in the game last Saturday was somewhat lost. We'd made some chin-stroking changes - dropping Anel to the bench for Bash, Flecky now joining the long term injured, no Khadra and McAtee coming in to get his first start and one would hope we'd get hold of Luton Town in our teeth and shake the fuckers in the way a terrier shakes a farmyard rat to break its spine and neck and kill it early.

But the first half was unimpressive to be honest. We didn't seem to have a system and were effectively bossed and bullied in areas of the pitch where we should have had more effect. Ex-Blade Luke Freeman, a seemingly past-it benchwarmer/treatment table wage stealer had a decent game and bossed our midfield almost single headedly showing flashes of skill and vision maybe we have lacked for too long. When Luton offered him a home when we released him I thought, 'good luck with that fucker'. Now he's in some sort of resurgence and found buckets of time to thread balls, make runs and put Sander Berge in the front row seats (fairly as well) and run off with the ball. Our midfield three could cope with him or his fellow midfielders.

Their goal was one bit avoidable but three bits bad marking. The replay shows Morris plonked firmly between Norwood and Basham and completely unchallenged, which if you are defending a cross from the zone is unforgivable. TO be able to leap and touch the ball like that and steer it into the net is a lesson of touch-tight-marking. I doubt Anel would have let him get away with that. Again, we are weak at defending the cross and again, we pay for it. It's notable - when opposition teams cross the ball into our six yard box there always seems to be a player or two who has bags of time to attack the ball and get it toward our goal yet when we cross it, the opposition penalty area is congested and packed and they (usually) deal with our ball easily.

Our midfield again today was the outcome of the result. In the first half, Berge couldn't find effective ways forward and didn't like being pressed and robbed and McAtee looked well over his head in a man's game. Norwood didn't do too badly but he again was sometimes profligate so without those options and settled pattern of play, our impetus was on McBurnie and NDaiye who at times looked on a hiding to nothing despite a lot of effort. McBurnie's goal was deserved and very, very welcome, but the post-equaliser ten minutes were not capitalised upon and we did spend a lot of time tentatively defending Luton's breaks whilst offering nothing much in return.

Foderingham 6/10: Decent game with a good, if pointless, save. Hope he recovers quickly.
Baldock 7/10: Enjoyed his performance and unlucky to be booked. I would like him to cut in diagonally at times and head toward goal, Bogle-style. Some decent defensive interventions
Basham 6/10: Sometimes a shaky return and other times consummate and composed with some decent defensive headers. Should have been a lot tighter marking for their goal, however
Egan 6.5/10: Once again marshalled the defence well when needed and put in his usual dogged spirit but he doesn't like the old ball over the top, does he?
RND 5/10: He works hard does Rhys, but I maintain - he's NOT a Centre Back. His shortcomings and tactical nous in effectively defending are made up by liability-wresting and 'mixing it up' which is okay when you are Chris Morgan or Virgil Van Dyk. He defends as a CB like he's playing LWB still and tonight he was bullied to fuck
Lowe 5.5/10: A quiet, practically vanilla game for him. Didn't see him in advanced positions much which told me all I need to know about his game and the fact that tonight he played like a flat-four LB rather than a marauding LWB in a 3-5-2
Berge 5.5/10: Thought he was outplayed and outmuscled most of the game, and vanished for long periods, even more so after taking a seat in the stands
Norwood 7/10: Another improved performance even if error prone at times. Good efforts on goal
McAtee 2/10: Very poor and our weak link in that first half. There were too many periods where he was outran, showed poor control, shite distribution and looking like an academy player blooded too early. Let's not get too bone hard on the hype on this lad, or we'll be back in Woodburn territory. If he is that magical, we need to see it materialise, because tonight, he was pretty dogwazz.
NDaiye 7/10: Again a great, grafting outing where he is the only point to deliver to and goes and gets it at all costs. We got another 15 out of him tonight as well which was good
McBurnie 7/10: Drops a whole mark for me because although we have a new McBurnie in the team now, the old one comes through like a stubborn skidmark. Just wish he'd get on with the game and stop the shithousery (the diving, the wrestling, the arms-up-appealing-to-the-ref because, as we have seen, he lurks in the shallows and can give us that bite we need. Fucking epic goal from him and deserved celebrations. Thank fuck he is off the mark now and hopefully ... there's more to come.

Doyle 6/10: A considerable upgrade on McAteer. Much more endeavour however not a great deal to show for it
Amissah 7/10: Giant of a keeper and looks commanding, taking his first cross with ease and producing a quality stop late on from Jerome
Anel 6/10: Looked a lot more solid with him at the back
Brewster 6/10: Still underfed and reliant on digging out his own chances. Scuffer of a shot late on, one of three for us

As said, a point is a point and all that. But we lack at times that 'gets you out of your seat' capability and spend a lot of time either doggedly defending or simply passing it about like in a practice match. Again, the midfield is guilty of not carrying it up the pitch and doing what MGW used to do with aplomb, namely put them on a the back foot and afraid to tackle. Khadra was (I believed) the answer to this but tonight he wasn't anywhere near the squad. Without that capability and potential on the pitch we will see a lot of games like this one tonight.

pommpey

First

pommpey
He's picked the wrong team and for me th most worrying thing is that this is the 2nd game already when he's played Berge deeper and it hasn't worked. Doyle to start the next match alongside Norwood.

McAtee was also at fault for the goal, he doesn't shut down the crosser of the ball , who has forever to pick his pass.

TBF we got Luton when they were right at it, so an away point isn't the end of the world
 
Agree on the whole. We looked very flat and slightly clueless first half, but I think we looked the better team after the break and probably should have won. That being said, a draw was probably about right and Luton probably felt like they could have snatched it too.

Felt a bit for McAtee, but this is exactly the sort of shit that he needs to learn in this league and learn quickly. All part of the challenge and risk with loan players. I still think he will come good.

UTB
 
Agree on the whole. We looked very flat and slightly clueless first half, but I think we looked the better team after the break and probably should have won. That being said, a draw was probably about right and Luton probably felt like they could have snatched it too.

Felt a bit for McAtee, but this is exactly the sort of shit that he needs to learn in this league and learn quickly. All part of the challenge and risk with loan players. I still think he will come good.

UTB
These are the tests that will differentiate him from a Woodburnesque failure and a Dean Henderson success. Jury’s out but the manager threw him under the proverbial bus tonight. Only saving grace was he admitted his mistake at half time and the game wasn’t gone.
 
Agree with pretty much everything Pomps - thanks again for the report.
I fear that Berge will get the same treatment every game now. Norwood was sussed in the PL and was pressed so hard he ended up playing deeper and deeper. He has a habit of turning infield every time he gets closed down and had his pocket picked several times as a result. He has to be played in the 10 slot or benched for away games. My score for him would be a 4.
Norwood looks like scoring now which is great to see but he seemed to set the tone for the second half by hitting long balls and others copied. I can only assume that this was an instruction from Hecky. Baffling as the first 15 of the second half we played football and they looks all over the place.
I have been one of McB’s biggest critics but thought he was terrific given the stick he was subjected to. Agree with the histrionics but he kept his head and I’d give him an 8.
 
Luton are a horrible side to play against it is all about disrupting the opposition for them every game is a battle. That being known McAtee was the wrong choice as a starter and to play him forward and pull Berge back destroyed our midfield. Hecky tried it before it didn't work then and it didn't work last night. The poor kid was like a rabbit in the headlights a bit like when as a youth on a kick about with your mates your younger brother tags along and is not up to it physically. We have to keep Berge in that forward midfield role, have to. We were a lot better when Doyle came on, not sure where RND got bullied not sure where McBurnie was shithousing it is hard not to wrestle when people grab you in a headlock and pull you to the floor. I know ref's have been instructed to let more physical contact go but come on Baldock gets booked for a shoulder charge yet Luton players drag our lads to the deck and hold them down and it goes unpunished. Poor ref for me but this directive might just suit the Luton style of play I didn't have them as making the play off's this season but I might just have to have a rethink on that they are going to be a tough team to play against if ref's let them get away with the spoiling tactics.
 
I thought Doyle would have started instead of McAtee but we’re talking in hindsight tbf Luton are a Dave Bassett kind of team so I’m not prepared to knock them as we’ve been there. Re Baldock cutting in I was thinking the same myself not sure George would know what to do if clean through though. Nice report Pomps, I’m happy ‘ish’ with a point away from home.
 
My take.

Thought Luton raised their game, Jones was extremely complimentary afterwards. I was also impressed, they battled, out fought us and kept their shape. This is probably going to be in their top 3 performances all season and they still didn’t beat us.

They played a Warnock esque style, which suits them and plays to their strengths, we used to beat better teams at home under Warnock so I don’t see too much of an issue coming back with a point. They’re not the better team, but at home and with the performance levels they more than matched us. They can’t sustain that every week.

Hecky messed up starting McAtee, I understand reservations of Doyle getting 90 etc. but no way he starts if Fleck, Osborn etc aren’t injured. Think that played into Luton’s approach in the first half.

McBurnie, RND and Baldock were a best players, that’s because they’re our little usual battlers. If we had Sharp, Fleck and Osborn playing, their tenacity and experience wins that game for us.

Our play was fast but often stifled by their shape, they did a fantastic job on Berge and Iliman. So much so they were marked out the game.

Not one for flair and tricks, one for the battlers, but most of ours are injured. We take a point and move on.
 
I thought Baldock was excellent - MOTM for me and his best game in ages. He got lots of blocks and scrappy (in a complimentary way) tackles in all game. Exactly what we needed.
 
A point is a point and its not three given away. But even the most happier of clappers might concede that although we remain top of the league for tonight at least, one feels that the momentum gained in the game last Saturday was somewhat lost. We'd made some chin-stroking changes - dropping Anel to the bench for Bash, Flecky now joining the long term injured, no Khadra and McAtee coming in to get his first start and one would hope we'd get hold of Luton Town in our teeth and shake the fuckers in the way a terrier shakes a farmyard rat to break its spine and neck and kill it early.

But the first half was unimpressive to be honest. We didn't seem to have a system and were effectively bossed and bullied in areas of the pitch where we should have had more effect. Ex-Blade Luke Freeman, a seemingly past-it benchwarmer/treatment table wage stealer had a decent game and bossed our midfield almost single headedly showing flashes of skill and vision maybe we have lacked for too long. When Luton offered him a home when we released him I thought, 'good luck with that fucker'. Now he's in some sort of resurgence and found buckets of time to thread balls, make runs and put Sander Berge in the front row seats (fairly as well) and run off with the ball. Our midfield three could cope with him or his fellow midfielders.

Their goal was one bit avoidable but three bits bad marking. The replay shows Morris plonked firmly between Norwood and Basham and completely unchallenged, which if you are defending a cross from the zone is unforgivable. TO be able to leap and touch the ball like that and steer it into the net is a lesson of touch-tight-marking. I doubt Anel would have let him get away with that. Again, we are weak at defending the cross and again, we pay for it. It's notable - when opposition teams cross the ball into our six yard box there always seems to be a player or two who has bags of time to attack the ball and get it toward our goal yet when we cross it, the opposition penalty area is congested and packed and they (usually) deal with our ball easily.

Our midfield again today was the outcome of the result. In the first half, Berge couldn't find effective ways forward and didn't like being pressed and robbed and McAtee looked well over his head in a man's game. Norwood didn't do too badly but he again was sometimes profligate so without those options and settled pattern of play, our impetus was on McBurnie and NDaiye who at times looked on a hiding to nothing despite a lot of effort. McBurnie's goal was deserved and very, very welcome, but the post-equaliser ten minutes were not capitalised upon and we did spend a lot of time tentatively defending Luton's breaks whilst offering nothing much in return.

Foderingham 6/10: Decent game with a good, if pointless, save. Hope he recovers quickly.
Baldock 7/10: Enjoyed his performance and unlucky to be booked. I would like him to cut in diagonally at times and head toward goal, Bogle-style. Some decent defensive interventions
Basham 6/10: Sometimes a shaky return and other times consummate and composed with some decent defensive headers. Should have been a lot tighter marking for their goal, however
Egan 6.5/10: Once again marshalled the defence well when needed and put in his usual dogged spirit but he doesn't like the old ball over the top, does he?
RND 5/10: He works hard does Rhys, but I maintain - he's NOT a Centre Back. His shortcomings and tactical nous in effectively defending are made up by liability-wresting and 'mixing it up' which is okay when you are Chris Morgan or Virgil Van Dyk. He defends as a CB like he's playing LWB still and tonight he was bullied to fuck
Lowe 5.5/10: A quiet, practically vanilla game for him. Didn't see him in advanced positions much which told me all I need to know about his game and the fact that tonight he played like a flat-four LB rather than a marauding LWB in a 3-5-2
Berge 5.5/10: Thought he was outplayed and outmuscled most of the game, and vanished for long periods, even more so after taking a seat in the stands
Norwood 7/10: Another improved performance even if error prone at times. Good efforts on goal
McAtee 2/10: Very poor and our weak link in that first half. There were too many periods where he was outran, showed poor control, shite distribution and looking like an academy player blooded too early. Let's not get too bone hard on the hype on this lad, or we'll be back in Woodburn territory. If he is that magical, we need to see it materialise, because tonight, he was pretty dogwazz.
NDaiye 7/10: Again a great, grafting outing where he is the only point to deliver to and goes and gets it at all costs. We got another 15 out of him tonight as well which was good
McBurnie 7/10: Drops a whole mark for me because although we have a new McBurnie in the team now, the old one comes through like a stubborn skidmark. Just wish he'd get on with the game and stop the shithousery (the diving, the wrestling, the arms-up-appealing-to-the-ref because, as we have seen, he lurks in the shallows and can give us that bite we need. Fucking epic goal from him and deserved celebrations. Thank fuck he is off the mark now and hopefully ... there's more to come.

Doyle 6/10: A considerable upgrade on McAteer. Much more endeavour however not a great deal to show for it
Amissah 7/10: Giant of a keeper and looks commanding, taking his first cross with ease and producing a quality stop late on from Jerome
Anel 6/10: Looked a lot more solid with him at the back
Brewster 6/10: Still underfed and reliant on digging out his own chances. Scuffer of a shot late on, one of three for us

As said, a point is a point and all that. But we lack at times that 'gets you out of your seat' capability and spend a lot of time either doggedly defending or simply passing it about like in a practice match. Again, the midfield is guilty of not carrying it up the pitch and doing what MGW used to do with aplomb, namely put them on a the back foot and afraid to tackle. Khadra was (I believed) the answer to this but tonight he wasn't anywhere near the squad. Without that capability and potential on the pitch we will see a lot of games like this one tonight.

pommpey

First

pommpey
Yet again I find myself agreeing with the bulk of your assessment dude!

Luton are a very physical side, but also a good side and they'll be up there again this season.

But after the previous battle from a physical Blackburn side I think we equipped ourselves well albeit the injury list adds a couple more to it!

Losing Wes is a big worry, although the young lad did ok and looked confident.
But who do we have as back up now?

Again we were sloppy at times, one of those times leading to their goal and the weakness of McAtee in midfield made it difficult for us.

Doyle is different gravy and made a big difference second half.

Around I thought we looked ok to good, still time to progress and improve.

Finally, Praise where praise is due for McBurnie. Yes, there I've said it....and for the second game in a row!
Took his goal well and worked his socks off against a tough defence. Just keep the concentration and stop waving your arms about lad....Oh and try and get into the box BEFORE the ball is crossed!

Now if only Brewster can get a goal 🤔
 
For their goal, Basham is caught between two men. One at the front post, one in the centre of the goal.

He's watching the player angling to cross and quickly decides that the player that poses more of a threat is the guy positioned between the posts - which is Egan's man.
Basham drops back to cover him, leaving Morris (who is now in front of the front post) unmarked. From there, it's a great finish from Morris to glance that into the far corner.

Egan is left in no man's land, not really covering anyone. I have to assume he didn't shout for Basham to push onto the man at the front post as he had the middle of the goal covered.

It's a shambles of a goal to concede and you'd think with over 100 appearances next to each other they'd be able to communicate a lot more effectively.
Egan often gets a free pass with our fans but he doesn't organise that back line very well.

Let's hope Ahmedhodzic and Clark are both ready to start on Tuesday. It'll make a big difference.
 
Looked like they had an extra player on the pitch for most of the game,failure to cut out crosses and win the subsequent second,third and sometimes fourth ball after those crosses went in caused most of our problems,they hunted in packs, pressed and won ball and moved it on quickly to the wide areas around the box.Until we get a physical prescience to get around our half and put out fires,many away games,are going to fit like this one last night
 
Lots of things to be happy about last night. A decent performance. A great point away against a tough team. Players starting to be more consistent week in, week out. McBurnie scoring after putting in more effort over the last few games than he has done in his Blades career, particularly when the team needs him to step up in Billy's absence.

One major negative. Their goal. Five players surrounding two of their players at the back post and yet the player who scored went unmarked. Piss poor defending yet again and yet another goal conceded from a player completely unmarked in the box. Clearly Hecky isn't communicating his set piece defending very well as this happened all of last season, or it comes down to piss poor communication between players, where Egan needs to take some blame as the so called "leader" at the back. Future captain my hole!

Still, way more positives than negatives.
 
Last edited:

Good assessment pommps. RND is a very makeshift LCH and Lowe looks dodgy defending, Our left flank looks a major weakness which Luton played on. Berge cannot play deep and neither he or Norwood respond well when pressed (all evident in the Blackburn game). Last night we played against 11 men not 10 and that was the difference. McAtee was very poor and should have been subbed 1st half - Doyle was a definite improvement against that type of opposition.

Freeman has been a thorn in our side since his Stevenage days - always seems to play well against us. Its a shame he didn't make it for us. Basham looked shaky and their goal was down to him and Norwood and Egan allowing a free header (and McAtee for not pressurising the crosser). Who was Egan marking exactly? McB took his goal very well but the shithousery really does detract from his effectiveness (he would do better learning from Billy about how to win a free kick and when to do it). Plaudits to George for tonight (having no left foot is probably why he doesn't cut inside). Ndaiye is far from the finished article but is the real class in our side and he is not a shrinking violet (unlike Berge - 5.5/10 flatters him - last night I would have given him a 4 including a mark off for being nesh and for letting Freeman put him in the stands). Very much a work in progress but a point is a point - injuries are already hurting us this early on in the season.
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom