My take ...

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

In previous 'my takes', there were always one or two minor points that I would have a different opinion on, but watching yesterday's game, I knew that this time out, it would be spot on.

From the moment I saw the line up to the final whistle, my thought way why they seemed to read Pommpey's my takes and focus on implementing all the shittest bits that he highlights. Yesterday, it was like they went for a full on Greatest Hits of all pommpey's steaming turds.
 

awful team selection again i agree with another poster i think were just setting up to make it tight and lose by the odd goal but we need more possesion to have any chance we need to play 451 imo
 
Another deeply disappointing and very predictable outcome. It's no wonder really. We are down on options and down on capability, now playing like the found-out, Championship evel team since the first kick of the ball versus Villa after the lockdown. Aside from small spells of looking like we can do it - Spurs, Chelsea, Man U ... we've been dismal and beaten for ages. Step forward Mr Wilder. This is your shout.

Fulham play a game full of chance, error and some mistakes. It's still 'just-up-from-the-Championship-dice-shaking' but fuck me don't they do it well? White shirt - white shirt - white shirt - white shirt, it is no wonder they out possessed us all fucking game. When we got it it was panic stations and look for the players that weren't there, so pump it long to McPub, the telegraph pole we bought for twenty odd million. Fulham however played it into the spaces we weren't, namely our ineffective, consistently overran midfield. Wilder thought he'd give Norwood a break this eek and start with the frankly useless Lundstram in CM and Basham RM but it was abundantly clear Lundstram is worse than Norwood in that berth and the only player who could fill the requirement was Ampadu. So the swap out happened. It didn't make much difference. The return of Jimmy Fleck from hospital and Ampadu basically covering for Lundstram too meant we were simply - once again - passed around and beaten all ends up in the middle of the park by Loftus-Cheek, Zambo and Reed feeding the dangermen in front of them or just running on past. They are so ineffective, that our only outlet is to pump it long and readers, tonight I counted one header out of about eleven or twelve which went to a green shirt (Fleck, first half) So why fucking do it? Oppositions just know that when he's on the pitch it's 'back to Ramsdale, BOOM! BOING! Thank-you-very-much'. There's a statistic that in our first half, our team

'DIDN'T TOUCH THE BALL IN THE OPPOSITION'S PENALTY AREA IN THE FIRST HALF'

Just hoist that in for a moment. Our strikeforce at the moment is an expensive lanky foul-claimer, a stout, 35 year old veteran, another veteran who kinda plays his own mellow game against the opposition, Billy Whizz with flip-flops on and what looks like a 14 year old schoolkid. Oh, and some fucking fraudulent footballer more keen on fast-food than fast-goals. And we play a system which has three inept individuals who are there to impose and make a difference on the outcome of the game in the middle of the park and a variable backline leaking injuries and confidence. And we can't even get a Sheffield United boot on the ball in 45 minutes, against what will be, one of our main rivals next season for getting back into the Premier League. It's dogshit, with mayo-fucking-nnaise on it.

Second half the changes, even when forced through losing Basham made no difference, in fact it made it worse. Okay, Stevens broke through but did you actually think he'd coolly pick his spot and drill the ball in the far corner? Did anyone think that Norwood's frankly brilliant cross would result in the net bulging? Nah. We are resorting to whinging about what was to me an obvious penalty as some sort of safe mattress to land on to spare our deep seated embarrassment and disappointment at being, once again, rolled over in the flour and batter, and dropped in the oil. We didn't do anything in that 97 minutes to suggest we deserved a result. We were simply crap, again.

Lastly, anyone deluded enough to think that armed with what they think is a Championship set of title-winning galacticos next season needs to have a big old whaft of the freshly ground beans. Playing like we did tonight, against one of our rivals, we're very likely to end up disappointed. We need to shed the deadwood, pay off their mistakenly-signed contracts, and start buying playmakers and goalscorers and play like we did in 2018-19. Right now we are a billion miles away from that and we have a hefty amunt of those players still pulling on a shirt, and the same management team. Blame COVID, narrow margins and 'lack of confidence' all you want, but this is down to them and Wilder, Our team's failures is their fault, and certainly not ours.

Ramsdale 7/10: Thought he had a better game. Good, confident stops and no fuck ups. Distribution was billy bollocks at times though, with most of them going via Pubby's melon or into empty space
Baldock 6/10: Nice to se him back. Aggressive and committed. Hope Furious is one of the players he especially intends to keep next season
Ampadu 5/10: Still working his ticket and hoping for home, back to Chelsea. Better than Lundstram in CM but horrific fuck up with Lookman for their goal
Jagielka 6.5/10: Poor old feller. Shows proper PL defensive class at times with key interceptions and headers, but at times, because he's 52, he's easy to skip round
Bryan 6/10: Didn't think he did too bad. Had his hands full at times with the likes of Cavaliero and Maja, but it was a passable display
Stevens 3/10: Shit finish when clean through. His game was proper Pompey too.
Basham 6/10: You know you'll get 100% out of him, even if RCM is not his bag. And tonight it wasn't, because he had no support or connectivity and was largely firefighting in the centre of the park, trying to get a way forward. Obviously better when CW switched him to RCB
Lundstram 1/10: Very poor, ineffective and frankly switched off performance in both positions. Can't wait for him to fuck off, to be honest. He's gone from Nicky Montgomery to Michael Doyle, in fact, Doyle was possibly better, in honesty
Fleck 4/10: Mysteriously back from hospital when everyone feared the worst. Was this John or was this Jimmy? You decide. I though like Lundstram, there as nothing to show that did anything to make us have an effect. One good free kick in the first half, that was it.
McBurnie 2/10: Pretty abject and no real positive comments. In fact I am wondering why I am giving him '2'. I suppose it's just in case he comes on here full of rage and gets stuck in to me again. '2' is slightly more 'respectful' than '0', I suppose. Tonight he was a fucking phone mast which every green shit bounced the ball off to surrender possession. If you think, with this system and tactics, he will be 'amazing' and 'rip the championship to bits' next season then you need a fucking terror shake. Unless we paly a different system and use him as a proper target man, second ball for striker #2, he's redundant. Twenty million.
Sharp 2/10: As ever, Billy gets a low mark because Billy got no service. You can't give him 7/10 for simply unning after the ball and hooking a cross over the top

Norwood 4/10: Typical weak performance. Two corners - first ma. Next one far post (okay, it found Bryan, but it needs to go into the triangle drawn from penalty area to posts, Gets an additional point for that superlative cross in that Sharp spooned, but I guess that's it for this season. All his fanboys will be hoping he gets kept on next season on that on single flash in the pan, when for the rest of the game he was simply passed around and bullied.
Bogle 7/10: Immediately invoked and should have started in RCM in my humble opinion. He poses far more attacking and positional guile than anyone on the pitch, actually and if any signing Wilder has made has proven himself worthy of the fee, it's him. The goalkeeper challenge was a penalty IMHO. Bogle touched the ball first and the keeper cracked his shins. I think the shysters in Stockley had given up on us by that time and were parked on the pot sliding out a loaf of brown clay because I have no idea what the fuck they were looking at that didn't say 'foul'.

But big deal. We are shit. We lost. Again. I know people say 'you're negative' but where are the positives? There are none, are there. Wilder is like a fucking stuck record both on the field and off the field post match, his signings are failures and his team now patently not good enough for the higher echelons of English football. And if it were Adkins in charge, he'd have been burnt at the stake by now.

Fire away. I'm ready.

pommpey
I think that is pretty fair assessment.
Nothing to add, I'm too pissed off from watching that garbage last night.
On CW i keep swinging from Wilder must stay to Wilder must go - today it's the latter - tomorrow it will be the former!
 
Nah. We are resorting to whinging about what was to me an obvious penalty as some sort of safe mattress to land on to spare our deep seated embarrassment and disappointment at being

I think we are now whinging for a penalty because thats the only way we are going to score for rest of season. I thought this in the first half and its true.
 
Don't read them, then. Sorted.

And 'cringeworthy'? Really?

You and your 'till the day I stop breathing' bladeyness?

I'm really starting to think someone has hijacked Silents account, you know. An adolescent girl or summat.

You're not who you used to be.

A bit like United, in fact.

pommpey
I dont fully read your reports, I stop reading when you put in puerile names such as McPub. What I did yesterday to look for your thoughts on the non penalty award and I was very surprised that you were slating at the ref instead of Wilder or any of our players. It isnt like you ! ;)

I know you dont really support United, you are just an egomaniac!
 
Although they both get 2/10 here, I think you're giving Billy a lot more slack than you give McBurnie. There is absolutely no doubt that we play a different (worse!) style when McBurnie plays, but the blame there should be on WIlder not McBurnie. The stats for the strikers were:

View attachment 106111

This tells some quite clear stories.:

McBurnie got involved a lot but, as you say, the ball bounced off him to the opposition. Only 11 completed passes from 38 touches (25 of which were 'attempted passes'). I'd argue that he can only do as well as the service he gets, and this was terrible all game. Aimless punts for him to try and wrestle and win a header. It clearly doesn't work, yet we persist with it. As was pointed out elsewhere, McBurnie only got one decent pass all game. He took it well, fed Sharp, who fed Stevens...

Sharp had only 9 touches all game. Again, this might be down to service (if we're just aiming at McBurnie's head, what can Sharp do). However, I'm sorry to say that nine touches over 90 minutes is just an absolute waste of a player. When you factor in his 3 offsides and 2 fouls, that's 5 times he gave freekicks away (versus his 4 completed passes). We would have been better off playing one up front and having an extra midfielder (Bogle).

McGoldrick had more involvement than Sharp despite playing only 17 minutes. In game where we were absolutely crying out to be able to hold onto the ball, it was unfathomable why we started with our two least possession-based strikers.

Finally... that 'shots' row. Zero, zero, zero. This was a game that we absolutely had to win to salvage any hope for the season, and not one of our strikers tried a single shot.
Absolutely spot on, unfortunately Sharp sums up perfectly why we are so shit in this league, a great pro, decent player and club hero but not premier league in the slightest, no other club would have him in their 11.

You have players like Gareth bale who cant get game time in the prem, our competitors have players like ruben loftus cheek/lookman/pereira etc and we have some right cloggers in comparison. Pub standard quality

Sharp was absolutely awful yesterday but both strikers had nothing but aimless punts to chase like dogs. When we are already lacking quality i dont think smashing it into space and relying on them to control the ball is helping them.
 
And you say Wilder's like a stuck record.
What about your comments in your reports?
Every week the same, 'Norwood not good enough, Stevens useless, hit and hope to McB not working, no goal threat, over-run in midfield.....
.....errrm, oh yeah, ummm, sorry mate.
That's because every week the team and manager are like a stuck record. Have you not noticed this, or are you more able to spot the "unseen work " and skilled ball play than I am??
 
Absolutely spot on, unfortunately Sharp sums up perfectly why we are so shit in this league, a great pro, decent player and club hero but not premier league in the slightest, no other club would have him in their 11.

You have players like Gareth bale who cant get game time in the prem, our competitors have players like ruben loftus cheek/lookman/pereira etc and we have some right cloggers in comparison. Pub standard quality

Sharp was absolutely awful yesterday but both strikers had nothing but aimless punts to chase like dogs. When we are already lacking quality i dont think smashing it into space and relying on them to control the ball is helping them.
And yet last year these same players were superb and we adored them. The manager was the best ever- are we really that fickle we turn on the lot of them and site a load of mercenaries as the answer.

Please- a little respect a little loyalty- yes it's gone badly wrong but to tout them as cloggers and pub team quality is a total disgrace- this team and staff gave us the best year we've had for 50 odd years. Of course it hurts playing so poorly last night, of course every week we hope for better - but turning on them - not for me- no way no how.

Basham, Enda, Baldock, Egan, Norwood, Fleck, Goldy, Chris and Al - deserve another go last year- and I believe most SUPPORTERS will get right behind you.

C'mon you red and white wizards..
 
I dont fully read your reports, I stop reading when you put in puerile names such as McPub. What I did yesterday to look for your thoughts on the non penalty award and I was very surprised that you were slating at the ref instead of Wilder or any of our players. It isnt like you ! ;)

I know you dont really support United, you are just an egomaniac!

I think you do. I doubt you stop, instantly as soon as I type 'McPub'. You're more of an oddbin if you click on 'My take ... ', scroll through and as soon as there's a name you get all gripe water about then stop reading out of some aloof 'principle' thinking, 'that'll hurt pommpey. I stopped reading, me. He doesn't know this so I'm gonna go onto one of his annoying posts and tell him, an' all!'

I couldn't give a fat rat's arse if you don't read any of my posts, ever again Silent. GYAC, just so it doesn't burn your retinas and make you want counselling, many 'My takes ...' from now on will definitely contain mild insults and chides against Sheffield United players ... if they play shit. They might not however if they don't. I'm not gonna put a health warning on them because I have been doing this for a few years now and you know what you'll get. Outstandingly detailed, blow-by-blow analysis from Deadbat (and a podcast!), sly digs, arse and poo snarkiness with a punch up in the car park afterwards from me. It's 'My take ... ' on the game. Doesn't have to be yours, I don't expect you to agree with me (although after last night, plenty do, for all the right reasons). But if it hurts your soul, please don't expect me to stop. Just ig-fucking-nore.

And you won't get me posting up teenage banners to reconfirm my alliance with a team I have supported as long as you have. I've spent almost three quarters of my life away from the city I was born in and the football team I love. There's no ego in that, especially given we have been shit-on-toast for most of that yet when I play lunchtime footy, I still pull on a Blades top and discuss how shit or good we were at the weekend during the warm up. You've been a long standing asset to all boards I have been on in the past twenty five years with your almost spectrum-like factoid spoddiness. Don't know who scored in a match? Ask Silent. Who was sub that day, and was it raining? Ask Silent. Which sleeve of their parkas did fans wipe their arses on when the shithouse paper ran out in the kop bogs v Notts Forest 18 Dec 1971*? Ask Silent. So don't speak to me about 'ego', whatever you do, eh?

And yay - how the fuck can I blame Wilder for what was, yet again, another VAR fuck up against us? Can't say we thoroughly deserved it, but I would have taken the point. But Wilder is big on that and small of mea culpa, isn't he? I think that's what fans need to hear to be honest. He has fucked up big style this year with team selections, system, playing formations, tactics and buying shit players, with shit players playing a shit system. It's a compounding set of circumstances and one that come next season when all of this pain is fading to a dull ache and we are looking forward to our new season as 'relegated Sheffield United who dropped with record number of defeats on 'x' points' he needs to sit down at the first press conference and admit he fucked up one of the greatest opportunities we have had since the second world war to capitalise on investment and lofty position to make our club - OUR club ... mine and yours - worthy of the city it hails from.

*Me and me dad were on the BLLT that day. The bogs were still out of shit-tickets, and I didn't use my parka but used my right sock. Don't tell me dad though. He'd kill me. ++

++He died in 1999. RIP Frank.

pommpey
 
Last edited:
And yet last year these same players were superb and we adored them. The manager was the best ever- are we really that fickle we turn on the lot of them and site a load of mercenaries as the answer.

Please- a little respect a little loyalty- yes it's gone badly wrong but to tout them as cloggers and pub team quality is a total disgrace- this team and staff gave us the best year we've had for 50 odd years. Of course it hurts playing so poorly last night, of course every week we hope for better - but turning on them - not for me- no way no how.

Basham, Enda, Baldock, Egan, Norwood, Fleck, Goldy, Chris and Al - deserve another go last year- and I believe most SUPPORTERS will get right behind you.

C'mon you red and white wizards..

What's the relevance of 'SUPPORTERS'?

Is it that anyone who criticises, isn't actually a supporter? Is that how you see it? Really?

Yours is another 'ignore this year, let's get all chubby about last year' special, isn't it?

Tell me. If the unthinkable happens and we drop straight through every trapdoor possible and end up like Bolton did - in the fourth tier of English Football - at what point will you (as in 'you') stop referencing the 2018-19 season and half the 2019-20 season as justification for Wilder's mistakes?

pommpey
 
What's the relevance of 'SUPPORTERS'?

Is it that anyone who criticises, isn't actually a supporter? Is that how you see it? Really?

Yours is another 'ignore this year, let's get all chubby about last year' special, isn't it?

Tell me. If the unthinkable happens and we drop straight through every trapdoor possible and end up like Bolton did - in the fourth tier of English Football - at what point will you (as in 'you') stop referencing the 2018-19 season and half the 2019-20 season as justification for Wilder's mistakes?

pommpey
i can just see it. Fifteen games in next season and we are hovering above the drop zone or even in it, there will be people saying “Wilder got us out o‘ League 1 before, eh we could get 100 points again like last time the’ noes, it’ll be reight“.
 
Great post Pommpey. Can I ask one question? What would your team selection , with positions & tactics , plus sub bench personnel be? Also a Plan B? Not trying to knock but it's "easy" to criticize after the fact. I would agree if you declined to answer as you aren't getting the £1 million to do the job.
Keep up the posts - best laughs of this awful season.🤣
 
I think you do. I doubt you stop, instantly as soon as I type 'McPub'. You're more of an oddbin if you click on 'My take ... ', scroll through and as soon as there's a name you get all gripe water about then stop reading out of some aloof 'principle' thinking, 'that'll hurt pommpey. I stopped reading, me. He doesn't know this so I'm gonna go onto one of his annoying posts and tell him, an' all!'

I couldn't give a fat rat's arse if you don't read any of my posts, ever again Silent. GYAC, just so it doesn't burn your retinas and make you want counselling, many 'My takes ...' from now on will definitely contain mild insults and chides against Sheffield United players ... if they play shit. They might not however if they don't. I'm not gonna put a health warning on them because I have been doing this for a few years now and you know what you'll get. Outstandingly detailed, blow-by-blow analysis from Deadbat (and a podcast!), sly digs, arse and poo snarkiness with a punch up in the car park afterwards from me. It's 'My take ... ' on the game. Doesn't have to be yours, I don't expect you to agree with me (although after last night, plenty do, for all the right reasons). But if it hurts your soul, please don't expect me to stop. Just ig-fucking-nore.

And you won't get me posting up teenage banners to reconfirm my alliance with a team I have supported as long as you have. I've spent almost three quarters of my life away from the city I was born in and the football team I love. There's no ego in that, especially given we have been shit-on-toast for most of that yet when I play lunchtime footy, I still pull on a Blades top and discuss how shit or good we were at the weekend during the warm up. You've been a long standing asset to all boards I have been on in the past twenty five years with your almost spectrum-like factoid spoddiness. Don't know who scored in a match? Ask Silent. Who was sub that day, and was it raining? Ask Silent. Which sleeve of their parkas did fans wipe their arses on when the shithouse paper ran out in the kop bogs v Notts Forest 18 Dec 1971*? Ask Silent. So don't speak to me about 'ego', whatever you do, eh?

And yay - how the fuck can I blame Wilder for what was, yet again, another VAR fuck up against us? Can't say we thoroughly deserved it, but I would have taken the point. But Wilder is big on that and small of mea culpa, isn't he? I think that's what fans need to hear to be honest. He has fucked up big style this year with team selections, system, playing formations, tactics and buying shit players, with shit players playing a shit system. It's a compounding set of circumstances and one that come next season when all of this pain is fading to a dull ache and we are looking forward to our new season as 'relegated Sheffield United who dropped with record number of defeats on 'x' points' he needs to sit down at the first press conference and admit he fucked up one of the greatest opportunities we have had since the second world war to capitalise on investment and lofty position to make our club - OUR club ... mine and yours - worthy of the city it hails from.

*Me and me dad were on the BLLT that day. The bogs were still out of shit-tickets, and I didn't use my parka but used my right sock. Don't tell me dad though. He'd kill me. ++

++He died in 1999. RIP Frank.

pommpey
A very long winded post from someone who doesnt give a rat's arse? Strange!
 

You have players like Gareth bale who cant get game time in the prem, our competitors have players like ruben loftus cheek/lookman/pereira etc and we have some right cloggers in comparison. Pub standard quality

You need a reality check kiddo, if you are comparing Bale and Loftus Cheek to our players
Spurs have Bale on loan from Real probably on north of £200k per week and Loftus Cheek is allegedly on £150k per week, Lookman on approx £100k per week
 
In a time long ago, so long ago that every team in the land played 4-4-2, your correspondent played up front for a shite side whose home ground was the playing fields on Ringinglow Road.

The pitches, naturally, on slopes with angles Pythagoras could not conceive, and the wind would drive through like spears of ice. For the most part the surface would be clods of sloop, long studs disappeared in it within less than a minute adding about 3 lbs of weight to each foot I would guess at.

On these days, I would gather up what strength I had when, say, the right back had the ball, and make a run into space, darting away from my marker in slow motion due to the conditions, only to find the ball sailing 20 feet over my head and bouncing thirty yards away where a different opposing defender had plenty of time to recover the ball under no pressure.

This scenario would play itself out with the unwavering, demoralising regularity of Comedy Central running repeats of Friends.

Although this took place almost 40 years ago, it came back to me last night when I watched McBurnie having to deal with the balls played up to him.

Poor kid.
 
And yet last year these same players were superb and we adored them. The manager was the best ever- are we really that fickle we turn on the lot of them and site a load of mercenaries as the answer.

Please- a little respect a little loyalty- yes it's gone badly wrong but to tout them as cloggers and pub team quality is a total disgrace- this team and staff gave us the best year we've had for 50 odd years. Of course it hurts playing so poorly last night, of course every week we hope for better - but turning on them - not for me- no way no how.

Basham, Enda, Baldock, Egan, Norwood, Fleck, Goldy, Chris and Al - deserve another go last year- and I believe most SUPPORTERS will get right behind you.

C'mon you red and white wizards..
I was vocal at the end of last season how we needed to improve and am pissed off that weve stood still/gone backwards, we were clearly punching above our weight last season, it was amazing to see but you can tell from their touch/creativity and general play that we needed to improve.

a few one of games like yesterday over a season than fine but about 70% of them are like that. They are all decent players but they are not prem standard, i’ve never thought Sharp has been either - this year or last. Loads of players who will ‘do a job’ is not good enough for this league and we’ve been naive in thinking it will.

The players/manager have given us some amazing moments but they are not immune from criticism and more importantly are not bigger than the club itself. If you want to play in the big boy leagues then in the words of chris wilder then there is no room for sentiment.
 
You need a reality check kiddo, if you are comparing Bale and Loftus Cheek to our players
Spurs have Bale on loan from Real probably on north of £200k per week and Loftus Cheek is allegedly on £150k per week, Lookman on approx £100k per week
The comparison is valid, im not saying we should have signed bale, im highlighting the quality needed to compete/survive in this league. We have recruited poorly and spent 8 figures to achieve mediocrity. It was clear to all that our midfield needed some major upgrades and an injection of creativity after last season yet we haven't addressed it.
 
By the way 'terror shake' is a naval term.

When your watch relief is characteristically one of those shits who acknowledges their consciousness when you shake them for a night watch and simply rolls over and gets his fat napper down again, you are not-too-small-amount-at-all unimpressed at his tardiness. So the next shake they get is an uncompromisingly brutal one ... one which involves some fierce physical shaking, loud gestures, sometimes violence, slapping, sometimes physically being hauled from your bunk onto the deck. It certainly focusses your attention on getting your shit together, ready for your watch. You lazy fucking cunt.

I have had a few terror shakes, sometimes unrequited because usually I would set my alarm rather than be a recipient. Terror shakes aren't nice.

pommpey
Talking of naval terms, I wonder if anyone realizes that 'SHIT' is also one. It stands for "Store High In Transit." This refers to Merchant Ships transporting Guano ( bird muck) from Peru to the UK in the days of sail. If it was stored in the hold it used to stink the place out, hence storing it high meant that it got as much ventilation as possible during the homeward run. I realize that this is way off topic, but the term seems to describe our predicament perfectly ATM.
 
A very long winded post from someone who doesnt give a rat's arse? Strange!
No. I don't give a rat's arse if you read my threads, or posts.

Which clearly you still do.

Here you go.

McPub.

pommpey
 
No. I don't give a rat's arse if you read my threads, or posts.

Which clearly you still do.

Here you go.

McPub.

pommpey
You love criticising our players and our managers and giving them puerile names. That doesnt make you a Sheffield United supporter
 
You love criticising our players and our managers and giving them puerile names. That doesnt make you a Sheffield United supporter
Your account HAS been hacked, hasn't it?

Foxy? Lindz? Help Silent get his account back will you? Seems one of the paperboys has taken it over .

pommpey
 
Talking of naval terms, I wonder if anyone realizes that 'SHIT' is also one. It stands for "Store High In Transit." This refers to Merchant Ships transporting Guano ( bird muck) from Peru to the UK in the days of sail. If it was stored in the hold it used to stink the place out, hence storing it high meant that it got as much ventilation as possible during the homeward run. I realize that this is way off topic, but the term seems to describe our predicament perfectly ATM.
Not true.

 
The comparison is valid, im not saying we should have signed bale, im highlighting the quality needed to compete/survive in this league. We have recruited poorly and spent 8 figures to achieve mediocrity.

The comparison is not valid
We have recruited within our budget / wage structure those players are beyond our means
Im sure Wilder would have been happy to be able to sign any of those players. He couldnt
Its a totally different question if you think our budget was not sufficient to ensure PL survival
 
Great post Pommpey. Can I ask one question? What would your team selection , with positions & tactics , plus sub bench personnel be? Also a Plan B? Not trying to knock but it's "easy" to criticize after the fact. I would agree if you declined to answer as you aren't getting the £1 million to do the job.
Keep up the posts - best laughs of this awful season.🤣

My team selection for Liverpool would be

------------------------------------------Ramsdale------------------------------------------

--Baldock-----------------Jagielka----------------------Bryan----------------------Lowe--

------------------------------------------Ampadu-------------------------------------------

---------------Bogle----------------------------------------------Osborn-------------------

----------------------------------------McGoldrick-----------------------------------------

--------------------------Burke---------------------------Brewster-------------------------

Basically giving the central two the chance to drop when we lose possession to for the 5-3-2, but move forward to make midfield passing opportunities.

Of course, we could bring Pubby on later and just aim it at the top of his melon, Sub Jags for Norwood and drop Ampadu back into the back four and go Wilderball.

And still lose.

But seriously, that formation would be a start, even if it played flatter or even in a 4-3-1-2.

We play a set strategy, which is the wide overload which hasn't worked since lockdown #1. The fallback is 'lump it to Pubster'. This is shitola too.

We don't overload the midfield and that is where we are getting reamed. The three we play there are still playing Championship style, formulaic nonsense and it's beatable, especially with the regressive skillsets they have. Norwood isn't a defensive midfielder, in fact I am not sure what he is apart from a just-capable distributer. He is crap in the tackle and can't challenge, his movement forward of the centre circle is full of risk. Let's say we replace him with a more capable ball winner and retainer in McGoldrick. Yeah, I know he's essentially a striker but he does have a lot better positional sense, is difficult to get the ball off and can win a tackle. And he can carry the ball. Outside of him you have two younger, attack minded defenders-cum-midfielders and reading Bogle and Osborn's game, they want it more and are hungrier to push on. They can also tackle better than Fleck and Lundstram. Behind them you have the regista in Ampadu, okay, not exactly Pirlo, but could grown into the role. And up front, pace. With Bogle, McGoldrick and Osborn facing forward and in their half, there are better opportunities for Buke and especially Brewster - who has a massive point to make in this match - to capitalise and grab his first goal. We do need to play down the middle though and get stuck in and win the ball in the centre, drive on and capitalise on half chances and long shots. Their keeper is good, but he can be a fuck up waiting to happen. That needs exploiting, preferably from distance. We don't do distance shots. Accurate, on target distance shots.

How do we cope with Firmino, Salah and co? Well, four teams have beaten them recently. There's plenty of evidence committed to video to study that. We just need to stop switching off when Liverpool are looking like they are about to score (like George Baldock didn't when he cleared off the line, last night, for example)

Not saying Liverpool are beatable, but they will be set up to beat us because they know we only play one or two set ways. Might be a good idea to change it.

pommpey
 
Don't read them, then. Sorted.

And 'cringeworthy'? Really?

You and your 'till the day I stop breathing' bladeyness?

I'm really starting to think someone has hijacked Silents account, you know. An adolescent girl or summat.

You're not who you used to be.

A bit like United, in fact.

pommpey
Is that really necessary ?
 

Is that really necessary ?
Is Silent 'stopping reading when he read pommpey making a naughty nickname about a United player then making a big pissfest out of it' necessary?

Why not just scroll-the-fuck-past? I'm not likely to be chastised on a football forum for making a nickname of a player, am I?

An Silent isn't Silent any more. I think someone like Topcat has hijacked his account. It's got his fingerprints all over it. Silent used to be stoic, reserved and somewhat humourless, but above all of this. Now he's down with the dickheads getting all butthurt thinking some nobody on a dark corner of internet forum is badmouthing McBurnie. Got nowt against McBurnie the man. Don't know him (however the 'offering out of opposition supporters') doesn't garner much faith. But as a footballer, he's done nowt for us this season except be a conduit between Ramsdale's boot and the opposition. Yet Silent is tripping over his bottom lip over me being pissed about that. P'raps he sees summat different? P'raps you do?

pommpey
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom