will we actually spend?????????

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

davidpinder

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
4,222
Reaction score
1,151
Location
Dronfield
Plenty of rumours about our players leaving, but i haven't heard that we are after anyone?. I read just over a month ago we were recruiting in January however so far its only really one in, Seip on loan. Cressy has signed was already here.
Is this usual united bullshit or are we just staying quiet.
 

I will be absolutely gob-smacked if we spend a single penny!

Mind you, with Blackwells track record I'm not sure I want him to either!
 
Blackwells record of getting player in isn't that different to anyone else. He buys some good ones and some that dont work out. Everyone does that.

As for this month, it is only the 8th, and if we've been good at one thing consistantly, it has been keeping the lid on deals until they are done. If the papers are talking about deals then they are probably just made up*...




(*No. Really? Do journalists do that???)
 
blackwell will want to keep his deals secret, after what happened with andrew surman in the summer, and blackwell ended up looking a right fool
 
Blackwells record of getting player in isn't that different to anyone else. He buys some good ones and some that dont work out. Everyone does that.

As for this month, it is only the 8th, and if we've been good at one thing consistantly, it has been keeping the lid on deals until they are done. If the papers are talking about deals then they are probably just made up*...




(*No. Really? Do journalists do that???)

I cannot believe people say this - is it a wind-up Duncs?

He has signed some utter garbage and the main problem is that when he goes relatively big as with Cotterill and Evans it goes horribly wrong.

The only good signing has been Ward. It is as simple as that. Williamson doesn't count because he is a crock and has been sod all use to us.
 
simple ................. NO, well not without new investment/owners.
 
I will be absolutely gob-smacked if we spend a single penny!

Mind you, with Blackwells track record I'm not sure I want him to either!

:lol: If we are to believe Killa is now staying I doubt we will do much business. I think an influx of new signings was dependant on raking something in on him.

The sale of Cotterill might fund a new winger (possibly). If we do anything I think it would be one football league player on the cheap. It would'nt surprise me to see one new face through the door at the last minute. I would guess we will probably stick with what we have though.
 
Plenty of rumours about our players leaving, but i haven't heard that we are after anyone?. I read just over a month ago we were recruiting in January however so far its only really one in, Seip on loan. Cressy has signed was already here.
Is this usual united bullshit or are we just staying quiet.

Chill Pinders!!(Whilst I'm uploading a photo)
Panic.jpg
LucyPinder4.jpg
 

:lol:
The sale of Cotterill might fund a new winger (possibly). If we do anything I think it would be one football league player on the cheap. It would'nt surprise me to see one new face through the door at the last minute. I would guess we will probably stick with what we have though.


The sale of cotterill funded the purchase of cresswell.
 
I cannot believe people say this - is it a wind-up Duncs?

He has signed some utter garbage and the main problem is that when he goes relatively big as with Cotterill and Evans it goes horribly wrong.

The only good signing has been Ward. It is as simple as that. Williamson doesn't count because he is a crock and has been sod all use to us.

I think that is a bit harsh Micalijo. Would you not consider Harper a good signing?

Don't get me wrong, I'm certainly not condoning Blackwell's transfer dealings, but he has made a couple of decent signings. Williamson could potentially be one. What about Henderson? Although i guess the context of that is that we lost Hulse to by Henderson.

Blackwell has signed, and particularly loaned, some absolute rubbsih. But this is only part of the problem. When he signs decent players (Evans, Harper, Halford, Coterill, Treacy) then he fails to get the best out of the players anyway.
 
I think that is a bit harsh Micalijo. Would you not consider Harper a good signing?

Don't get me wrong, I'm certainly not condoning Blackwell's transfer dealings, but he has made a couple of decent signings. Williamson could potentially be one. What about Henderson? Although i guess the context of that is that we lost Hulse to by Henderson.

Blackwell has signed, and particularly loaned, some absolute rubbsih. But this is only part of the problem. When he signs decent players (Evans, Harper, Halford, Coterill, Treacy) then he fails to get the best out of the players anyway.

I think we can add Camara to Blackwells decent signings list also ...
 
I will be absolutely gob-smacked if we spend a single penny!

Mind you, with Blackwells track record I'm not sure I want him to either!

Just thinking about what Torrix said. I've attempted to summarise Blackwells transer dealings. I've starred the people who I rate (or think are any good). Apologies if I've missed anyone, as I'm doing this from memory, but I think I have most.

In's

Ward *
Hendo *
Creswell
Williamson *(?)
Reid
Camara *
Fortune
Stewart
Taylor
Little
Bromby
Coterill *

on loan: Treacy*, Harper*, Seip, Davies, Kalio*, Halford*, Stokes, Spring, BT (2), Ikelme, Bunn, O'Toole.

Outs

Beattie *
Walker *
Naughton *
Coterill *
Hendire *
Hulse *
Armstrong *
Ehiogu *
Webber
bromby
Gillespie *
Sun Jihai
Carney
Tonge *

It's certain that we've lost a lot more talent than we have brought in. However it has been a difficult job for KB. He has obviously been told by KM to decrease the wage bill. Not only that but some transfers (BT, Walker/Naughton) have been out of his hands.

However something that is a major problem for me is Blackwell bring ing in players that are not better (often worse) than what we have got. Creswell is an example of this. Others are Stewart, Taylor, Davies, Bromby, Little, Fortune, Spring, O'Toole and Stokes. Other than to have back up this kind of policy will get you nowhere. It doesn't increase competition for places and is probably the reason why we'll finish around mid table this year.

Another highly frustrating aspect of KB's transer policy is his knack of a) seemingly not giving players a chance and b) playing players out of position (both these extends to older players as well as new signigns). Coterill, Evans and reid are examples of players he's signed and then refuses to give a proper chance. So far he's played Walker, Stewart, Ward, Cresswell and Halford all out of positon on a consistent basis.

From this it's difficult to see a compelling argument as to why McCabe should give Blackwell any money in January.
 
I think that is a bit harsh Micalijo. Would you not consider Harper a good signing?

Don't get me wrong, I'm certainly not condoning Blackwell's transfer dealings, but he has made a couple of decent signings. Williamson could potentially be one. What about Henderson? Although i guess the context of that is that we lost Hulse to by Henderson.

Blackwell has signed, and particularly loaned, some absolute rubbsih. But this is only part of the problem. When he signs decent players (Evans, Harper, Halford, Coterill, Treacy) then he fails to get the best out of the players anyway.

Fair enough. I rate Henderson, overpriced but decent. Harper hasn't had much influence for me but I'd rather have him than not.

And Duncs - I do genuinely disagree with 99% of everything you ever say on United and property developers!! I aint doing it for the sake of it. You are allowed to debate and discuss rather than say how boring it is etc etc.
 
Naughton on loan and Tongey and a decent keeper on permanents would do for me - don't think that's too much to ask.

I'd also love to see Gregory back, but he's said he's not going anywhere.
 
Blackwell has made some poor signings but who has been scouting these players ?
Surely the scouts, if we have any are partially to blame for overating these players.
Do you sack the manager but keep the same scouting staff ?
 
Naughton on loan and Tongey and a decent keeper on permanents would do for me - don't think that's too much to ask.

I'd also love to see Gregory back, but he's said he's not going anywhere.

Tonge? Why?
 
Blackwell has made some poor signings but who has been scouting these players ?
Surely the scouts, if we have any are partially to blame for overating these players.
Do you sack the manager but keep the same scouting staff ?

Very good point, well made Toronto ...........................

Mind yer who wud want to be a scout for the Blades ? ........
what a thankless job ! look at the trouble we have attracting quality to BDTBL.
an in my opinion its all to do with lack of ambition.
 

And Duncs - I do genuinely disagree with 99% of everything you ever say on United and property developers!! I aint doing it for the sake of it. You are allowed to debate and discuss rather than say how boring it is etc etc.

I've got an idea. Don't bother reading and replying to any of my posts and that will save us from the tedium of the 'non-discussion' that follows...
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom