No. I questioned your comments. You got shirty.
You've now made a specific post about the medical into a general one about the "process" as a whole.
No one is saying he wasn't an expensive flop. It turned into a blame scenario. I put it firmly on the head of Mad Nigel, who knows more about football and medicals than any board member and pushed the deal through. With that ridiculous clause which it looks like it might have cost Brannigan his job, or at least the straw that broke the camels back.
This was Gray's post and my post in response.
↑
Possibly BB, if he could tackle cleanly, win headers and pass a ball, but for me he had absolutely nothing going for him, at least at this this stage of his career.
My point regarding the docs and physios was that they will have watched him run and timed him before he put pen to paper, and it's hard to imagine how it didn't raise a few eyebrows, assuming they'd looked at videos of him playing for Leicester. He never looked right from day one (in my opinion of course). Adkins more than anybody should have seen what he'd lost, which is why I think the whole deal, especially his 12 month extension option stinks mate.
Click to expand...
It was a poor signing and a big error of judgement from Adkins but we've signed players before who haven't been particularly fit, like Shipperly and McGrath.
What I would question, is how involved are our owners or their representatives in the process. Someone obviously gave Adkins the green light. After Wallace and Hogdon you'd think we'd look at these things, particularly given the amount of money we spent on him. Or do we just give the manager a blank cheque and then whinge when it doesn't work out?
And no, I'm not saying they should be constantly interfering but at some point in their career every manager is told 'no, you can't have him'. How many magic beans will we buy before we realise there's no such thing as a magic bean?
I stand by that, whether you agree or not. It's clearly supposition and I have made no attempt to pass it off as fact or ITK information. It's my opinion. I'm surprised the deal went through considering we've been caught out before. I can't really add to that without repeating myself.