Worst Full back of our L1 Years?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Worst full back?

  • Marcus Williams

    Votes: 61 35.7%
  • Matt Hill

    Votes: 4 2.3%
  • Andy Taylor

    Votes: 13 7.6%
  • Simon Lappin

    Votes: 11 6.4%
  • LJF

    Votes: 3 1.8%
  • Tony McMahon

    Votes: 10 5.8%
  • Daryl Westlake

    Votes: 53 31.0%
  • Craig Alcock

    Votes: 16 9.4%

  • Total voters
    171

Slim Man

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
7,475
Reaction score
11,412
This seems to just be a mass of left backs... we've been pretty sound at Right Back.

Any decent players miss out, obviously.
 



weve had some shite full backs but marcus williams takes the biscuit... surely he MUST win this !
an absolutly awful player at the best of times
 
Ah, poor Marcus. Football wasn't really his thing, was it?

Jeez we've had our share though. Realise space is limited and not everyone can be included, but (dis)honourable mention in passing to Aidy White is warranted, I reckon.
 
I actually thought McMahon was rather good, doesn't deserve to be on this list IMO wasn't the most charismatic but was committed and relatively solid, and has been a key player for Bradford this season

How about a vote for Jasper Johns? So bad he only played 45 minutes and was released

Made his own song called 'Failure':

https://soundcloud.com/jasper-johns-2
 
Can we vote multiple times ? :)

I think I'd still pick most of that lot ahead of Nyron.
 
Definitely Williams but god this is a shameful list. Surprised to see LJF on the list as always thought he was decent.
 
Definitely Williams but god this is a shameful list. Surprised to see LJF on the list as always thought he was decent.
He was to be fair but like I said 0% is a compliment :)
 
Technically there was worse... but fuck Daryl Westlake.
 



He was to be fair but like I said 0% is a compliment :)

A back handed one! Congratulations you weren't as awful as Hill, Williams, Alcock and westlake. I love those kind of compliments.
 
Before this year Kieran Freeman might have snuck in there
 
LJF should be nowhere near this list, up until this season he was arguably the best LB of the L1 years(!)

think Williams was probably the worst but "penalty specialist" Andy Taylor deserves a special mention too
 
I actually thought McMahon was rather good, doesn't deserve to be on this list IMO wasn't the most charismatic but was committed and relatively solid, and has been a key player for Bradford this season

How about a vote for Jasper Johns? So bad he only played 45 minutes and was released

Made his own song called 'Failure':

https://soundcloud.com/jasper-johns-2

McMahon deserves to be there not because he was such a shit player, it's because he was and still is an utter cunt.
 
Who voted Matt Hill as worse than Williams or Alcock?

Have a word with yourselves!
 
Lecsinel Jean-Francois should not be in that list. He was a bit of a fans favourite until he got injured badly in that fateful Oldham home game
 
Can't just vote for one of those, so I've ranked them by awfulness
  1. Marcus Williams - terrible
  2. Daryl Westlake - I can't remember anything about this guy
  3. Simon Lappin - desperate times
  4. Matt Hill - terrible but I had a soft spot for him, given that Wilson effectively said he was crap when he signed him, but he kept the shirt for 2 1/2 seasons
  5. Andy Taylor - didn't do anything well, apart from penalties, apparently
  6. Craig Alcock - shit, even worse at Centre back
  7. Tony McMahon - brain dead, but thought he was great. not the worst on this list by a mile
  8. LJF - I rated him, pity he got injured
 
Majority could all deserve this award. I think its harsh on matt hill & LJF.

I went for Andy Taylor as he was so slow main memory of him was how he managed to lose 60yd sprint with a 10yd headstart when opposition were counter attacking
 



LJF should be nowhere near this list, up until this season he was arguably the best LB of the L1 years(!)

think Williams was probably the worst but "penalty specialist" Andy Taylor deserves a special mention too
I wouldn't have but 3 votes suggests he ought to be on! He was a bit erratic at times but I did like him before Harry injured him... :)
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom