Who would you rather keep?

[Mousey]

Ok then, so a bid has been accept for Kyle Naughton and he will probably go to Everton for around £5m. But in all honesty who would you rather sell, him or Killa?

There was plenty of speculation around the end of the year that Kilgallon was on his way and that really would have been a blow to keeping the team intact. I see Kilgallon as an essential part of the team whereas with Naughton there is already another youngster (Walker) who seems capable to take his place.

 

[madeinsheffield]

still smacks of a lack of long term ambition, some days i get sick of the self inflicted hurt united cause us fans, what's so wrong with keeping them and building a team around these promising quality players???? FFS

 

[DazBlade88]

I'd rather keep all of them to be honest, but if I had to choose one to keep it would be Kilgallon.

Walker is a ready made replacement for Naughton but I can see Walker being a centre half in the future rather than a full back.

 

[KL Blade]

I'd rather keep all of them to be honest, but if I had to choose one to keep it would be Kilgallon.

Walker is a ready made replacement for Naughton but I can see Walker being a centre half in the future rather than a full back.

Good point and I share the same view on Walker eventually being a centre half. Other than the fact that there's a ready made replacement for Naughton in Walker, Kilgallon is good but still work in progress so hope he will develop and realise his full potential with us and help us get back to the promised land.

 

[Bladesman]

We wont keep either.

So no need for this poll really.

 

[Greg]

I've voted for Kilgallon. However, I think a lot of people will have voted for him simply because Naughton looks set to be on his way to Goodison.

 

[Macfarlane21]

Killa is class! Naughton is class! If we didnt have any good players this would not be a problem lol!

 

[fox1974]

Totally agree with mousey walker impressed me more than naughton towards the end of the season.

 

[Linz]

Killa is class! Naughton is class! If we didnt have any good players this would not be a problem lol!

Do not send this idea to the club