United players with books

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Stuart Davis

New Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
88
Reaction score
128
Just finished reading Paddy Kenny’s book. What other blades have autobiographies? I’m pretty sure Keith Gillespie has one. Any other fairly recent players?
 

Keith Gillespie - very good
Alan Hodgkinson - riddled with factual errors. Disappointing
Alan Birchenall - very funny
Keith Edwards - solid effort
Tony Kenworthy - solid effort, slightly better than Edwards
Vinnie Jones - not read though the United bit only occupies about 2 pages
Terry Curran - not read and wouldn't read
 

Keith Gillespie - very good
Alan Hodgkinson - riddled with factual errors. Disappointing
Alan Birchenall - very funny
Keith Edwards - solid effort
Tony Kenworthy - solid effort, slightly better than Edwards
Vinnie Jones - not read though the United bit only occupies about 2 pages
Terry Curran - not read and wouldn't read
Not read Gillespie's or Kenworthy's. Agree with what you said about Hodgy, Birch and Edwards. TC's biography a few years ago was good. Mick Jones's autobiography was more like a scrapbook than an autobiography. Have read John Tudor's but it had inaccuracies. Browsed Vinny Jones' and decided not to buy because I noticed that he was belittling us. A Blade across the road has lend me Paddy Kenny's, not read it yet.
 
I skipped to the bit about United in Curran's biography in WHSmith's. The only bit I can remember was him saying that he was in Josephine's with a girl and Tony Kenworthy warned Curran that his wife had turned up.
I also skipped to the United section in Martin Peters' autobiography. He said he had underestimated the hostility between United and Wednesday fans and that his kids got stick at school. He said he had expected to get more support from Harry Haslam when Peters took over as manager. He said that relegation thing to Division 4 wasn't the worst thing to happen in his time at SUFC, that was the death of Keith Solomon, the young keeper from Cornwall.
 
Keith Gillespie - very good
Alan Hodgkinson - riddled with factual errors. Disappointing
Alan Birchenall - very funny
Keith Edwards - solid effort
Tony Kenworthy - solid effort, slightly better than Edwards
Vinnie Jones - not read though the United bit only occupies about 2 pages
Terry Curran - not read and wouldn't read
A small addition to your comments on Hodgy’s book. It is indeed riddled with factual errors, some of them so basic that it is difficult to imagine how they came about. At the same time, I found it very readable, and felt it captured the spirit of football in the 1950s and 1960s very well; it also conveys his personality very well. Don’t let the errors put you off reading it if you want to re-live the era or gain a sense of football at the Lane in the 50s and 60s.
 
It's a good read.

I bought it for my dad, he said it's similar to most football autobiographies, just a bit more interesting with the Blade links.
 
hodgys book was a cracking read if you grew up in the 50s and 60s but did have factual errors main one being that we played west ham last day of the 67/68 relegation season edwards and kenworthys books are also good reads and suprisingly both were complimentary towards curran
 
A small addition to your comments on Hodgy’s book. It is indeed riddled with factual errors, some of them so basic that it is difficult to imagine how they came about. At the same time, I found it very readable, and felt it captured the spirit of football in the 1950s and 1960s very well; it also conveys his personality very well. Don’t let the errors put you off reading it if you want to re-live the era or gain a sense of football at the Lane in the 50s and 60s.
The ghost writer was a Stoke fan who knew little about the club and it seems he didnt check the facts properly
 

Is the list of United Players who have books out longer or shorter than the list of United Players who have actually read a book?
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom