United 1 Blackburn 1 - report/ratings

[Deadbat]

The Blades finished the season with a 1-1 draw at home to Blackburn Rovers, meaning they do end up 90 points but finished ultimately 10 behind both Leeds and Burnley for the top places. However, whilst United knew their fate in terms of league position, visiting Rovers had an opportunity to gatecrash the end of season party and after they took the lead through Ohashi, they were briefly in the top 6 positions. Ahmedhodzic’s leveller came not long after and the Blades missed a host of chances to win a game in which for long periods, they were the far superior side. However, late on Rovers threw bodies forward and won late corners with their goalkeeper in the box but were unable to fashion any clear chances late on and their hopes ended. Bristol City in the end take the final spot and will now face United over two legs – with the Blades hoping it will be a different result than the tie 37 years ago – when City won a two-legged tie in United’s first attempt at playoffs – at least in the modern era. Maybe this time it will be 10th time lucky!



As expected Wilder made a number of changes with seven incoming starters. Adam Davies got a rare start in goal and in came Gilchrist and Ahmedhodzic at the back. Peck, Brooks and O’Hare came in alongside Tom Cannon. It was maybe a surprise that both Hamer and Souza started with maybe the latter still needing game time to play himself into form. Hamer, of course, had been rested for the game at Stoke. Blackburn had been on an excellent late run and started with Ohashi up top, supported by Cantwell. They were backed by a sell out away following in the Bramall Lane upper tier.



The game started with United dominating the ball and Souza/Peck controlling things as Blackburn began quite cautiously as they maybe wanted to just stay in the game initially and then change the approach as the game went on. Hamer was involved often and his link play with O’Hare was a feature of the game. Blackburn had not really offered anything of note apart from Cantwell twice trying to con the referee with pathetic dives at the Kop end, who remembered similar antics from his Norwich days. The first real chance came when Cannon was fed down the right and his shot on the angle was saved by Toth. Hamer then had an effort wide as United looked to turn the screw and were dominating possession. Both teams were guilty of heavy touches and a fussy referee was not helping as Holding was cautioned for a foul. This was after Travis had poleaxed Hamer twice, with United fans holding their breath.



United had a great chance to lead when Brooks put over a great in swinging cross and Hamer met it but somehow his connection went over the bar. On reflection, a header may have been the right choice perhaps? Blackburn were not really offering much but out of nowhere; they nearly got an unlikely goal. Brittain’s cross-shot had to be dealt with by Davies and he did well to flick the ball behind. The first half ended with Rovers knowing that results elsewhere meant they were still very much in with a chance of making the playoffs.



The second half began with a more open feel and started to see gaps appearing. Peck had a shot blocked and then Hamer and O’Hare forced an opening that led to a corner, as United continued to look the more likely. However, after an attack broke down, Blackburn broke well at pace and had men over. Hedges found Brittain, whom in turn, fed OHASHI and his shot clipped Holding and went past Davies and there was jubilation in the away end. The ‘As its stands’ table had Rovers into 6th place with Bristol City trailing at home to Preston.



United did respond though only 9 minutes later as Hamer sent over a dangerous cross after a first attack had not been cleared. Holding met it and guided it perfectly into the path of his fellow centre half AHMEDHODZIC who toe poked home from close range. The Rovers fans’ glee was silenced quickly and just like that, they were out of the top 6, almost as quickly as they went into it!



The game now saw a flurry of chances with Brewster and Seriki on for the home side for Hamer and Gilchrist and Kargbo on for Hedges for the Lancastrians, with the latter looking like a bad injury as he could not put any weight on the ball as he left the field. United were moving the ball well through the central area and Brewster, now captain, was using the ball well and a few nice flicks saw half chances. O’Hare then worked some space with Brooks and the latter was starting to now attack his man.

Peck had another effort blocked, as did O’Hare and then a dreadful miss after brilliant work from Brooks saw the chance teed up via O’Hare for Cannon but he blazed over with the goal at his mercy.

Dennis and Gueye replaced Cantwell and Dolan for Rovers and One was on for Cannon for the home side. Soon after it was Forshaw and Woodrow for Travis and Tronstad. Davies then replaced Souza and it was clear Wilder now wanted to protect key players. Dolan offered a riposte with a long-range effort and Davies made a meal out of it, gathering at the second attempt. Blackburn had heard that Bristol City were now level but knew they still only needed another goal, if results stayed the game but were not exactly creating chance after chance. Brewster played in O’Hare who had a shot saved before O’Hare again did well and linked with Brooks but the ball was bundled behind



Burrows came on for McCallum as the game entered the final 5 minutes. Seriki went down after a challenge and was in some distress and had to go off holding his arm seemingly and it looked a really bad one as he was strapped up. One was in but he was selfish with men over and took the shot rather than a pass that may have led to the winner before Burrows conceded an unnecessary corner. Toth was up for this and a subsequent corner, but Dennis’ header well wide was the closest they got and United actually ended up on the attack to close the 8 (10 were played actually) additional minutes of time. The final whistle went and Blackburn players slumped to their knees whilst for United, attentions turn to the playoffs beginning on Thursday.



United – It was quite a fun game. Thought first half was bit of a grueller and little happened but we did play some decent stuff at times, if a little slow. Hamer was our main architect and looking to link with others but there were few chances until Cannon had the shot saved but Hamer should have scored from the Brooks cross. We struggled to get much going down the sides but attacked well down the middle – we have not see that and we did have some joy with this approach. Thought Blackburn looked poor and created very little other than the cross shot and trying to con the ref with penalties. I thought Hamer got little protection form a poor ref and I would have considered taking him off at half time to protect him – but he did go off before any damage could be done. I think Blackburn just wanted to be cautious but we had a few chances to be ahead so it was a risky tactic. WE had loads of ball but both teams were poor in possession and gave it away a lot but we looked a better side technically and had more creativity. They did then suddenly score out of nothing – decent break and finish – if deflected. After this though we scored not long after. Then for the final 30 minutes, it was entertaining. They sort of left gaps but not sure they had lots of men forward or created much either – they seemed caught in two minds. They threw subs on and the fans encouraged them to come forward but they looked leggy and we finished the stronger and had so many chances really. Cannon, O’Hare, One and a few others really should have got us a few goals. Cannon’s miss was appalling – he had been ok up to then too. It was odd, as we watched a timid and poor Blackburn side, that you thought we would beat over a two-legged playoff, you reckon so in your head you think losing a goal would maybe not the worst thing – but players do not think like that and even as a fan, you want to win of course. IF they had scored, I would not have been devastated but then they may have gone into the playoffs on a high. In the end, they had a few corners and tried to find something but never really had a clear chance – at least in comparison to the ones we created.



United should have won. The performance was better in terms of us creating things and the way we attacked but we had some vulnerabilities too at the back. I was pleased we saw O’Hare have a really good game and Brooks finished the game well – showing he could be a viable option from the bench. We showed flashes of at least some attacking play that saw chances created. The Seriki injury was a sour note of course. In terms of the week, we end the season in better form at least. Bristol City were better than us over both games I have to admit but they limped in (pitch invasion seemed a bit embarrassing and should be motivation – odd quirk they only got in because of us getting that leveller!). I think and hope we will play better against them. The team picks itself I think for 9 positions – Cooper, Choudhury, Burrows, Anel, Souza, Peck, O’Hare, Hamer and Campbell I reckon? Then it will be Holding or Robinson. I would pick the former – Wilder won’t sadly. He will then make the change for the second leg if it does not go well but needs to do it now. Not sure both were great today but feel better and less panicky with Holding there. The other picks will be Rak Sakyi or Brereton Diaz. I feel he may go for the latter away and then the former at home. I’d pick JRS as he at least keeps the defence back.



Am I confident? Nope. We always blow the playoffs somehow (50% of the 8 ties where the final was at Wembley/Cardiff, ee have got through – Bristol City of course in 1988 was not to get to Wembley) and you feel we might never win them (surely we will). However, not sure any of the other three are that great. I was glad to avoid Coventry – they are either really poor or blow teams away but will be tough at home and can score goals. Sunderland have been on wretched form but have shown they have pace/attacking threats. I am ok with who we play but we must ensure we start well, defend properly, and win the midfield battle. We cannot be passive and have to ensure that we do not play to score first rather than sit back. We will see. As it stands, I still think Coventry weirdly might be the team that goes up but we just need a few big games from our creative talents and Souza to be the player he can be to control midfield. We cannot say we go into this as underdogs and probably the bookies favourites but have to put in three good performances. Let’s see how Wilder and the players present and prove that they have been the third best team. Nervy times!

 

[Deadbat]

Ratings:



Davies 5/10 – Had little to do really. He pushed one cross shot over but outside of that not really needed first half - it was just routine stuff but at times showed he is not as good with his feet as Cooper and I never felt as confident. The goal may have been deflected slightly but I thought he might have done better to be honest? It seemed to go through him and went in fairly centrally and thought he was slow. Made one save from another but nearly made a mess of that as it bounced up – that was the only other shot second half.



Gilchrist 4.5/10 – He won a few tackles but we struggled all game down this side until Seriki came on and Brooks improved in the final period of the game. Thought he looked slow and his positional sense was lacking but Brooks constantly passing it back to him and not getting back to help was not ideal. Never got forward at all. He now will maybe be needed with Seriki injured but expect Choudhury to start.



McCallum 4.5/10 – With his feet, he is wretched at times and seems to make easy stuff more complicated. Takes a lot of heavy touches or gives it away. He remains good in the air and fairly athletic but he also seems to struggle to know when to push on, or hang back. He was more available at least as an attacking option than Gilchrist and to be fair did put 2 or 3 decent balls in despite my criticism. He should only be used if Burrows is injured or for the final spell of a game as cannot be trusted on the ball.



Ahmedhodzic 5.5/10 – He was ok but began the game with some errant touches and also committed a few silly fouls and was lucky not to be booked. He did come onto the ball and started to bringing the ball out and used it well. They came through the middle too easily on the goal but then scored the equaliser. Not sure him and Holding were totally comfortable but it was an open game.



Holding 5.5/10 – I like him but he gave it away a few times today – including one early on that nearly put them in. He also was a bit sloppy with his passing but did improve as the game went on. Their goal came off him but then he did put the header across to set up the equaliser.



Souza 6/10 – Thought he started quite well and moved it on, controlled the tempo but then started to make mistakes or overplay and got caught out. He looked a bit leggy 2nd half and glad we took him off. Still does not seem to have the same explosiveness of earlier in the season but we did see glimpses of better play.



Hamer 7/10 – Started the game as the stand out player and everything good came from him, getting on the ball and moving it forward. He showed some neat touches and worked well with O’Hare. He had one shot wide but then missed an absolute sitter. Not as involved after the break but did cross the ball for the goal. Glad he was taken off as Travis in particular was giving him some real hammer and my main worry was he would get injured. Did get involved in a silly spat too. Just get away from it!



Peck 7/10 – Thought he was very good most of the game and got on the ball, used it well and was the midfielder that seemed to be most involved. We had so much of the ball and he was at the heart of many things. He did make a mistake in the lead up to the goal though and his shooting continues to be poor – had 2 or 3 and snatched at them – seems almost too desperate. Overall, though continues to improve and look like he will go on and be a top, top player.



O’Hare 7/10 – I thought he started ok but got better and better and by the end was our best player. Everything we did 2nd half was due to him getting on the ball and linking with others. Some excellent dribbling and underrated strength on the ball too. He was a link all game and thought he showed incredible energy, on and off the ball. A lot of our chances came from his clever runs and was much more direct and effective at drawing men.



Brooks 5.5/10 – A really odd game and some will pan this mark but for 70 minutes he was dreadful. He put the one decent ball for Hamer -but outside of this, he was timid, came back and lost it. He also did not get back to defend to help Gilchrist. I was surprised he stayed on when we made so many changes but clearly Wilder wanted to preserve starters with the games to come. Then oddly when the game opened up and Seriki came on, we saw a different player and for 20 minutes he was very good at the end. Two or three weaving runs, bits of individual skill led to chances for a number of players – Cannon, O’Hare etc. It is frustrating it took so long for him to suddenly wake up. Showed he is probably only someone who is a bit of an impact sub as when given opportunities to start, not sure he has done enough. Expect Rak Sakyi to start or even Brereton Diaz in the week.



Cannon 5/10 – He actually did some ok things to be fair and was not as ineffectual in general play. Made some ok runs and had one shot saved and a few other pieces of decent link up but also showed his lack of upper body strength too. He shot once when others were well placed first half and did the same second half when the pass was the better option. However, despite an ‘ok’ game – nothing remarkable – will be remembered for his appalling miss when he blasted the ball over from 5 or 6 yards with the whole goal almost to aim at. It was an awful finish and showed his lack of composure. Worrying this is supposed to be his strength – finishing! Not sure he starts in the week – surely we go with Campbell?





Subs -



Brewster 6.5/10 – Thought he played quite well when he came on and got on the ball, competed, and made good choices with his play. Showed he is a decent passer of the ball and a few nice balls/flicks led to chances. Ended up captain too! Who would have thought that at the start of the season?! A decent option off the bench but do not feel he will start over O’Hare.



Seriki 6/10 – Did offer more than Gilchrist and defended well too when he had to. Gave us another outlet and looked lively. He won the ball over their sub (Kargbo?) and the Blackburn man thought he had fouled him – seemed to go in on him but maybe it was more an accident and Seriki went down in some distress. It was clearly more than a knock and looked like he may have broken his arm or even collar bone – he won’t be seen till next season that is for sure. A blow as he gives us a good option when we need it down the right. It is worrying that he picks up injuries a lot though and needs to get stronger but this one today seemed more of a freak one.



Davies 6/10 – Got about the pitch and nicked the ball – he also looked full of energy to sav it was his first game for a long time. He got in a few good attacking areas too and was well forward when we had breaks to seal the game.



One – Looks to have grown (height and physique) even more than when we last saw him. He got shrugged off a few times but had one good chance when he ran down the right but was very selfish and he shot when he had to look up and find a pass – showing his inexperience. Had three men screaming at him!



Burrows – Not sure why he was risked. One daft moment where he knocked the ball out when there was no need and led to them getting a late corner.



Manager: Wilder 6/10 – Made changes, we rested a few and we played some decent stuff and should have won the game. Some more poor moments at the back and still not sure we have that area sound enough but best we have looked attacking wise – in terms of creating things – albeit in a game where the opponents had to push up. We did not get any suspensions but did get that bad Seriki injury which was disappointing being so late on. Overall, we ended the season with two decent performances (we were ok at Burnley) and at least have a few players back in form seemingly or approaching it (Souza/O’Hare). Bristol City and Manning had more control of both games and their approach/tactics were better in both games. We did not have control of either game really – albeit led in the one at the Lane and scored two late goals to win at Ashton Gate. We have to be the ones who try and control midfield -we did not in either game and match their energy/youth. We need to be the aggressors and not sit back and wait for things to happen. If we defend and think of the second leg, it will be a disaster, as we have shown we rarely if ever come back from deficits. I think scoring first- even at their place is important. We do that and we have a great chance but if we go behind, then we are up against it and the crowd then becomes anxious -even if we trail by a single goal going into the game at the Lane.





Blackburn - They seemed to be out of it a few weeks ago as the decent form earlier in the season under Eustace, had dropped off and the new manager (who had been sacked at West Brom and Watford) had not really been able to get a response. Suddenly, the last few weeks they have started to win some games and hit form and they had a chance. I thought they would have really had a good go today but opted for the cautious approach in the end. They kind of wanted to stay in the game and then it worked as they score – but do not hold the lead long enough and really if we take our chances, they are well beaten. They had a bit of a go at the end with corners and lots of forwards on but United still looked more likely . They fell to the floor at the and the fans rightly applauded them for taking it to the end and a good season (I had them to go down so was miles off!). Today though they were not really good enough to win the game. I think they may struggle to replicate this next year in a division that will have strong teams coming up and down.



Opponent Man of the Match – Brittain had the effort saved and then set up their goal too. Tronstad had a few neat touches also but not sure anyone did enough really. Keeper made some decent saves



Opponent Weak link – Travis was filthy as always and Cantwell dived. Choose between either of these!



Referee/Officials – Farai Hallam. Thought he was poor. He booked a few of ours but kept his cards in his pocket for the Blackburn players who committed similar or worse fouls. He did not give us much at all. Was incredibly fussy and was a long time away from play too. We had a few reasonable appeals for a penalty I thought but hard to tell? Seemed to lose control towards the end with challenges going in from both teams.



Crowd – Decent atmosphere to say we had nothing to play for but helped with a big Rovers following who thought they would finally end a long of not winning at the Lane – 1994 – Shearer scored I think! They got behind their team and tried to rally them when they heard the results gave them a chance. In the end, their season is over but they at least took it to the last game. For United, we of course have another game and need a passionate and hostile home crowd when hopefully we are in the tie still and can go on and win it to get to Wembley. Ticket prices do seem a bit pricy but suppose depends what Bristol City wanted to charge too? I worry we may not even sell out – or am I way out on that thought? Hope not as we need the placed packed and noisy to give the team all the help they need.

 

[BalticBlade]

Were you watching the match under water?

 

[Gin&Juice]

You’re taking the piss a bit with Brooks. I get it’s subjective, and it’s a forum. But.. I feel some of the scoring is a symptom of your L’Equipe approach to ratings.

Don’t think Gilchrist and McCallum (as annoying as some of his mistakes were) deserve to be ranked so low.

 

[McGrath]

I thought Souza was ace today. He looked like prime time Souza from earlier in the season where he strode around as if he was a 16 year playing in an under 12s game

 

[Karaoke Blade]

You're not sure if Cannon should start in the week? I am. He shouldn't.

 

[Addison]

Thanks for your reports this season Deadbat appreciate the time and effort you put into them. I thought the Anel Holding combo did well. Its the first time as a 2 Anel has been left and Holding right. They were the other way round for Cardiff. There was some early positional uncertainty not least when they both went to head the same ball. They grew as a pair as the game went on both being involved in our goal. The stark difference between these 2 and having JLT in the team is our ability to play 10 yards further up the pitch when they are both in possession. Blackburn noticeably dropped deeper when Anel in particular drove at them. Both are better passers of the ball. Holding is more dominant in the air and Anel looks comfortable back on the left where he played with Souttar.

Despite my analysis I know Im wasting my breath because Robinson will be back for Bristol City. He and Holding started last time out at Home to BC. Anel came on at 70 minutes for Holding. We hadn't conceded at that point but Robinson gifted them an equaliser late on when BC's pacey winger got past him. I expect CW to go with Holding and JLT.

OHare last 2 games has been our best player imo. We retain possession better with his energy and work rate. Again I fear CW will opt for Brewster on the right and go with 4-4-2 as he looks to go long to counter BC's midfield control. Agree BC have dominated the midfield in both games previously. The sensible option imo is to go 4-3-1-2 with Hamer dropping into a 3 with peck and Souza. COH playing behind a two which should include Campbell and one other. It disrupts BC's possession game.

The problem is none of us know what CW's preferred formation will be for the play offs. Todays 4-2-3-1 dominates possession but scoring opportunities are limited. 4-4-2 provides more aerial threat and chance creation but leaves huge holes in midfield susceptible to the counter. 4-3-1-2 may provide the best of both.

Seriki is a big loss. Brookes looked better offensively because our one player who drives right down to the bye line was on his side of the pitch. Gilchrist or Choudhury will provide defensive steel alternatives but we lose the ability to have a player running direct at tiring defences late in the game. He would have been a revelation on Wembleys wide open pitch. Unfortunately that is now not to be.

Yes Davies was slow to get down to a deflected side foot. Shows what an asset Cooper has been.

We pick the right players and formation I maintain we have nothing to fear. We have to break the curse sometime. Ive been to 90% of the finals and seen us lose and not turn up every time. Maybe our luck will change as I'll not be able to go to the final this year. Thats if we get past Bristol City first.

 

[Frank the tank]

Ratings:



Davies 5/10 – Had little to do really. He pushed one cross shot over but outside of that not really needed first half - it was just routine stuff but at times showed he is not as good with his feet as Cooper and I never felt as confident. The goal may have been deflected slightly but I thought he might have done better to be honest? It seemed to go through him and went in fairly centrally and thought he was slow. Made one save from another but nearly made a mess of that as it bounced up – that was the only other shot second half.



Gilchrist 4.5/10 – He won a few tackles but we struggled all game down this side until Seriki came on and Brooks improved in the final period of the game. Thought he looked slow and his positional sense was lacking but Brooks constantly passing it back to him and not getting back to help was not ideal. Never got forward at all. He now will maybe be needed with Seriki injured but expect Choudhury to start.



McCallum 4.5/10 – With his feet, he is wretched at times and seems to make easy stuff more complicated. Takes a lot of heavy touches or gives it away. He remains good in the air and fairly athletic but he also seems to struggle to know when to push on, or hang back. He was more available at least as an attacking option than Gilchrist and to be fair did put 2 or 3 decent balls in despite my criticism. He should only be used if Burrows is injured or for the final spell of a game as cannot be trusted on the ball.



Ahmedhodzic 5.5/10 – He was ok but began the game with some errant touches and also committed a few silly fouls and was lucky not to be booked. He did come onto the ball and started to bringing the ball out and used it well. They came through the middle too easily on the goal but then scored the equaliser. Not sure him and Holding were totally comfortable but it was an open game.



Holding 5.5/10 – I like him but he gave it away a few times today – including one early on that nearly put them in. He also was a bit sloppy with his passing but did improve as the game went on. Their goal came off him but then he did put the header across to set up the equaliser.



Souza 6/10 – Thought he started quite well and moved it on, controlled the tempo but then started to make mistakes or overplay and got caught out. He looked a bit leggy 2nd half and glad we took him off. Still does not seem to have the same explosiveness of earlier in the season but we did see glimpses of better play.



Hamer 7/10 – Started the game as the stand out player and everything good came from him, getting on the ball and moving it forward. He showed some neat touches and worked well with O’Hare. He had one shot wide but then missed an absolute sitter. Not as involved after the break but did cross the ball for the goal. Glad he was taken off as Travis in particular was giving him some real hammer and my main worry was he would get injured. Did get involved in a silly spat too. Just get away from it!



Peck 7/10 – Thought he was very good most of the game and got on the ball, used it well and was the midfielder that seemed to be most involved. We had so much of the ball and he was at the heart of many things. He did make a mistake in the lead up to the goal though and his shooting continues to be poor – had 2 or 3 and snatched at them – seems almost too desperate. Overall, though continues to improve and look like he will go on and be a top, top player.



O’Hare 7/10 – I thought he started ok but got better and better and by the end was our best player. Everything we did 2nd half was due to him getting on the ball and linking with others. Some excellent dribbling and underrated strength on the ball too. He was a link all game and thought he showed incredible energy, on and off the ball. A lot of our chances came from his clever runs and was much more direct and effective at drawing men.



Brooks 5.5/10 – A really odd game and some will pan this mark but for 70 minutes he was dreadful. He put the one decent ball for Hamer -but outside of this, he was timid, came back and lost it. He also did not get back to defend to help Gilchrist. I was surprised he stayed on when we made so many changes but clearly Wilder wanted to preserve starters with the games to come. Then oddly when the game opened up and Seriki came on, we saw a different player and for 20 minutes he was very good at the end. Two or three weaving runs, bits of individual skill led to chances for a number of players – Cannon, O’Hare etc. It is frustrating it took so long for him to suddenly wake up. Showed he is probably only someone who is a bit of an impact sub as when given opportunities to start, not sure he has done enough. Expect Rak Sakyi to start or even Brereton Diaz in the week.



Cannon 5/10 – He actually did some ok things to be fair and was not as ineffectual in general play. Made some ok runs and had one shot saved and a few other pieces of decent link up but also showed his lack of upper body strength too. He shot once when others were well placed first half and did the same second half when the pass was the better option. However, despite an ‘ok’ game – nothing remarkable – will be remembered for his appalling miss when he blasted the ball over from 5 or 6 yards with the whole goal almost to aim at. It was an awful finish and showed his lack of composure. Worrying this is supposed to be his strength – finishing! Not sure he starts in the week – surely we go with Campbell?





Subs -



Brewster 6.5/10 – Thought he played quite well when he came on and got on the ball, competed, and made good choices with his play. Showed he is a decent passer of the ball and a few nice balls/flicks led to chances. Ended up captain too! Who would have thought that at the start of the season?! A decent option off the bench but do not feel he will start over O’Hare.



Seriki 6/10 – Did offer more than Gilchrist and defended well too when he had to. Gave us another outlet and looked lively. He won the ball over their sub (Kargbo?) and the Blackburn man thought he had fouled him – seemed to go in on him but maybe it was more an accident and Seriki went down in some distress. It was clearly more than a knock and looked like he may have broken his arm or even collar bone – he won’t be seen till next season that is for sure. A blow as he gives us a good option when we need it down the right. It is worrying that he picks up injuries a lot though and needs to get stronger but this one today seemed more of a freak one.



Davies 6/10 – Got about the pitch and nicked the ball – he also looked full of energy to sav it was his first game for a long time. He got in a few good attacking areas too and was well forward when we had breaks to seal the game.



One – Looks to have grown (height and physique) even more than when we last saw him. He got shrugged off a few times but had one good chance when he ran down the right but was very selfish and he shot when he had to look up and find a pass – showing his inexperience. Had three men screaming at him!



Burrows – Not sure why he was risked. One daft moment where he knocked the ball out when there was no need and led to them getting a late corner.



Manager: Wilder 6/10 – Made changes, we rested a few and we played some decent stuff and should have won the game. Some more poor moments at the back and still not sure we have that area sound enough but best we have looked attacking wise – in terms of creating things – albeit in a game where the opponents had to push up. We did not get any suspensions but did get that bad Seriki injury which was disappointing being so late on. Overall, we ended the season with two decent performances (we were ok at Burnley) and at least have a few players back in form seemingly or approaching it (Souza/O’Hare). Bristol City and Manning had more control of both games and their approach/tactics were better in both games. We did not have control of either game really – albeit led in the one at the Lane and scored two late goals to win at Ashton Gate. We have to be the ones who try and control midfield -we did not in either game and match their energy/youth. We need to be the aggressors and not sit back and wait for things to happen. If we defend and think of the second leg, it will be a disaster, as we have shown we rarely if ever come back from deficits. I think scoring first- even at their place is important. We do that and we have a great chance but if we go behind, then we are up against it and the crowd then becomes anxious -even if we trail by a single goal going into the game at the Lane.





Blackburn - They seemed to be out of it a few weeks ago as the decent form earlier in the season under Eustace, had dropped off and the new manager (who had been sacked at West Brom and Watford) had not really been able to get a response. Suddenly, the last few weeks they have started to win some games and hit form and they had a chance. I thought they would have really had a good go today but opted for the cautious approach in the end. They kind of wanted to stay in the game and then it worked as they score – but do not hold the lead long enough and really if we take our chances, they are well beaten. They had a bit of a go at the end with corners and lots of forwards on but United still looked more likely . They fell to the floor at the and the fans rightly applauded them for taking it to the end and a good season (I had them to go down so was miles off!). Today though they were not really good enough to win the game. I think they may struggle to replicate this next year in a division that will have strong teams coming up and down.



Opponent Man of the Match – Brittain had the effort saved and then set up their goal too. Tronstad had a few neat touches also but not sure anyone did enough really. Keeper made some decent saves



Opponent Weak link – Travis was filthy as always and Cantwell dived. Choose between either of these!



Referee/Officials – Farai Hallam. Thought he was poor. He booked a few of ours but kept his cards in his pocket for the Blackburn players who committed similar or worse fouls. He did not give us much at all. Was incredibly fussy and was a long time away from play too. We had a few reasonable appeals for a penalty I thought but hard to tell? Seemed to lose control towards the end with challenges going in from both teams.



Crowd – Decent atmosphere to say we had nothing to play for but helped with a big Rovers following who thought they would finally end a long of not winning at the Lane – 1994 – Shearer scored I think! They got behind their team and tried to rally them when they heard the results gave them a chance. In the end, their season is over but they at least took it to the last game. For United, we of course have another game and need a passionate and hostile home crowd when hopefully we are in the tie still and can go on and win it to get to Wembley. Ticket prices do seem a bit pricy but suppose depends what Bristol City wanted to charge too? I worry we may not even sell out – or am I way out on that thought? Hope not as we need the placed packed and noisy to give the team all the help they need.

 

[1973Blade]

I thought both Holding and Anel looked solid at the back. Hopefully they will be starting at Bristol City.

 

[Ceasefire]

Ratings:



Davies 5/10 – Had little to do really. He pushed one cross shot over but outside of that not really needed first half - it was just routine stuff but at times showed he is not as good with his feet as Cooper and I never felt as confident. The goal may have been deflected slightly but I thought he might have done better to be honest? It seemed to go through him and went in fairly centrally and thought he was slow. Made one save from another but nearly made a mess of that as it bounced up – that was the only other shot second half.



Gilchrist 4.5/10 – He won a few tackles but we struggled all game down this side until Seriki came on and Brooks improved in the final period of the game. Thought he looked slow and his positional sense was lacking but Brooks constantly passing it back to him and not getting back to help was not ideal. Never got forward at all. He now will maybe be needed with Seriki injured but expect Choudhury to start.



McCallum 4.5/10 – With his feet, he is wretched at times and seems to make easy stuff more complicated. Takes a lot of heavy touches or gives it away. He remains good in the air and fairly athletic but he also seems to struggle to know when to push on, or hang back. He was more available at least as an attacking option than Gilchrist and to be fair did put 2 or 3 decent balls in despite my criticism. He should only be used if Burrows is injured or for the final spell of a game as cannot be trusted on the ball.



Ahmedhodzic 5.5/10 – He was ok but began the game with some errant touches and also committed a few silly fouls and was lucky not to be booked. He did come onto the ball and started to bringing the ball out and used it well. They came through the middle too easily on the goal but then scored the equaliser. Not sure him and Holding were totally comfortable but it was an open game.



Holding 5.5/10 – I like him but he gave it away a few times today – including one early on that nearly put them in. He also was a bit sloppy with his passing but did improve as the game went on. Their goal came off him but then he did put the header across to set up the equaliser.



Souza 6/10 – Thought he started quite well and moved it on, controlled the tempo but then started to make mistakes or overplay and got caught out. He looked a bit leggy 2nd half and glad we took him off. Still does not seem to have the same explosiveness of earlier in the season but we did see glimpses of better play.



Hamer 7/10 – Started the game as the stand out player and everything good came from him, getting on the ball and moving it forward. He showed some neat touches and worked well with O’Hare. He had one shot wide but then missed an absolute sitter. Not as involved after the break but did cross the ball for the goal. Glad he was taken off as Travis in particular was giving him some real hammer and my main worry was he would get injured. Did get involved in a silly spat too. Just get away from it!



Peck 7/10 – Thought he was very good most of the game and got on the ball, used it well and was the midfielder that seemed to be most involved. We had so much of the ball and he was at the heart of many things. He did make a mistake in the lead up to the goal though and his shooting continues to be poor – had 2 or 3 and snatched at them – seems almost too desperate. Overall, though continues to improve and look like he will go on and be a top, top player.



O’Hare 7/10 – I thought he started ok but got better and better and by the end was our best player. Everything we did 2nd half was due to him getting on the ball and linking with others. Some excellent dribbling and underrated strength on the ball too. He was a link all game and thought he showed incredible energy, on and off the ball. A lot of our chances came from his clever runs and was much more direct and effective at drawing men.



Brooks 5.5/10 – A really odd game and some will pan this mark but for 70 minutes he was dreadful. He put the one decent ball for Hamer -but outside of this, he was timid, came back and lost it. He also did not get back to defend to help Gilchrist. I was surprised he stayed on when we made so many changes but clearly Wilder wanted to preserve starters with the games to come. Then oddly when the game opened up and Seriki came on, we saw a different player and for 20 minutes he was very good at the end. Two or three weaving runs, bits of individual skill led to chances for a number of players – Cannon, O’Hare etc. It is frustrating it took so long for him to suddenly wake up. Showed he is probably only someone who is a bit of an impact sub as when given opportunities to start, not sure he has done enough. Expect Rak Sakyi to start or even Brereton Diaz in the week.



Cannon 5/10 – He actually did some ok things to be fair and was not as ineffectual in general play. Made some ok runs and had one shot saved and a few other pieces of decent link up but also showed his lack of upper body strength too. He shot once when others were well placed first half and did the same second half when the pass was the better option. However, despite an ‘ok’ game – nothing remarkable – will be remembered for his appalling miss when he blasted the ball over from 5 or 6 yards with the whole goal almost to aim at. It was an awful finish and showed his lack of composure. Worrying this is supposed to be his strength – finishing! Not sure he starts in the week – surely we go with Campbell?





Subs -



Brewster 6.5/10 – Thought he played quite well when he came on and got on the ball, competed, and made good choices with his play. Showed he is a decent passer of the ball and a few nice balls/flicks led to chances. Ended up captain too! Who would have thought that at the start of the season?! A decent option off the bench but do not feel he will start over O’Hare.



Seriki 6/10 – Did offer more than Gilchrist and defended well too when he had to. Gave us another outlet and looked lively. He won the ball over their sub (Kargbo?) and the Blackburn man thought he had fouled him – seemed to go in on him but maybe it was more an accident and Seriki went down in some distress. It was clearly more than a knock and looked like he may have broken his arm or even collar bone – he won’t be seen till next season that is for sure. A blow as he gives us a good option when we need it down the right. It is worrying that he picks up injuries a lot though and needs to get stronger but this one today seemed more of a freak one.



Davies 6/10 – Got about the pitch and nicked the ball – he also looked full of energy to sav it was his first game for a long time. He got in a few good attacking areas too and was well forward when we had breaks to seal the game.



One – Looks to have grown (height and physique) even more than when we last saw him. He got shrugged off a few times but had one good chance when he ran down the right but was very selfish and he shot when he had to look up and find a pass – showing his inexperience. Had three men screaming at him!



Burrows – Not sure why he was risked. One daft moment where he knocked the ball out when there was no need and led to them getting a late corner.



Manager: Wilder 6/10 – Made changes, we rested a few and we played some decent stuff and should have won the game. Some more poor moments at the back and still not sure we have that area sound enough but best we have looked attacking wise – in terms of creating things – albeit in a game where the opponents had to push up. We did not get any suspensions but did get that bad Seriki injury which was disappointing being so late on. Overall, we ended the season with two decent performances (we were ok at Burnley) and at least have a few players back in form seemingly or approaching it (Souza/O’Hare). Bristol City and Manning had more control of both games and their approach/tactics were better in both games. We did not have control of either game really – albeit led in the one at the Lane and scored two late goals to win at Ashton Gate. We have to be the ones who try and control midfield -we did not in either game and match their energy/youth. We need to be the aggressors and not sit back and wait for things to happen. If we defend and think of the second leg, it will be a disaster, as we have shown we rarely if ever come back from deficits. I think scoring first- even at their place is important. We do that and we have a great chance but if we go behind, then we are up against it and the crowd then becomes anxious -even if we trail by a single goal going into the game at the Lane.





Blackburn - They seemed to be out of it a few weeks ago as the decent form earlier in the season under Eustace, had dropped off and the new manager (who had been sacked at West Brom and Watford) had not really been able to get a response. Suddenly, the last few weeks they have started to win some games and hit form and they had a chance. I thought they would have really had a good go today but opted for the cautious approach in the end. They kind of wanted to stay in the game and then it worked as they score – but do not hold the lead long enough and really if we take our chances, they are well beaten. They had a bit of a go at the end with corners and lots of forwards on but United still looked more likely . They fell to the floor at the and the fans rightly applauded them for taking it to the end and a good season (I had them to go down so was miles off!). Today though they were not really good enough to win the game. I think they may struggle to replicate this next year in a division that will have strong teams coming up and down.



Opponent Man of the Match – Brittain had the effort saved and then set up their goal too. Tronstad had a few neat touches also but not sure anyone did enough really. Keeper made some decent saves



Opponent Weak link – Travis was filthy as always and Cantwell dived. Choose between either of these!



Referee/Officials – Farai Hallam. Thought he was poor. He booked a few of ours but kept his cards in his pocket for the Blackburn players who committed similar or worse fouls. He did not give us much at all. Was incredibly fussy and was a long time away from play too. We had a few reasonable appeals for a penalty I thought but hard to tell? Seemed to lose control towards the end with challenges going in from both teams.



Crowd – Decent atmosphere to say we had nothing to play for but helped with a big Rovers following who thought they would finally end a long of not winning at the Lane – 1994 – Shearer scored I think! They got behind their team and tried to rally them when they heard the results gave them a chance. In the end, their season is over but they at least took it to the last game. For United, we of course have another game and need a passionate and hostile home crowd when hopefully we are in the tie still and can go on and win it to get to Wembley. Ticket prices do seem a bit pricy but suppose depends what Bristol City wanted to charge too? I worry we may not even sell out – or am I way out on that thought? Hope not as we need the placed packed and noisy to give the team all the help they need.

Thanks Deadbat for your excellent reports over the season. Really appreciate your hard work.

 

[Revolution]

The Blades finished the season with a 1-1 draw at home to Blackburn Rovers, meaning they do end up 90 points but finished ultimately 10 behind both Leeds and Burnley for the top places. However, whilst United knew their fate in terms of league position, visiting Rovers had an opportunity to gatecrash the end of season party and after they took the lead through Ohashi, they were briefly in the top 6 positions. Ahmedhodzic’s leveller came not long after and the Blades missed a host of chances to win a game in which for long periods, they were the far superior side. However, late on Rovers threw bodies forward and won late corners with their goalkeeper in the box but were unable to fashion any clear chances late on and their hopes ended. Bristol City in the end take the final spot and will now face United over two legs – with the Blades hoping it will be a different result than the tie 37 years ago – when City won a two-legged tie in United’s first attempt at playoffs – at least in the modern era. Maybe this time it will be 10th time lucky!



As expected Wilder made a number of changes with seven incoming starters. Adam Davies got a rare start in goal and in came Gilchrist and Ahmedhodzic at the back. Peck, Brooks and O’Hare came in alongside Tom Cannon. It was maybe a surprise that both Hamer and Souza started with maybe the latter still needing game time to play himself into form. Hamer, of course, had been rested for the game at Stoke. Blackburn had been on an excellent late run and started with Ohashi up top, supported by Cantwell. They were backed by a sell out away following in the Bramall Lane upper tier.



The game started with United dominating the ball and Souza/Peck controlling things as Blackburn began quite cautiously as they maybe wanted to just stay in the game initially and then change the approach as the game went on. Hamer was involved often and his link play with O’Hare was a feature of the game. Blackburn had not really offered anything of note apart from Cantwell twice trying to con the referee with pathetic dives at the Kop end, who remembered similar antics from his Norwich days. The first real chance came when Cannon was fed down the right and his shot on the angle was saved by Toth. Hamer then had an effort wide as United looked to turn the screw and were dominating possession. Both teams were guilty of heavy touches and a fussy referee was not helping as Holding was cautioned for a foul. This was after Travis had poleaxed Hamer twice, with United fans holding their breath.



United had a great chance to lead when Brooks put over a great in swinging cross and Hamer met it but somehow his connection went over the bar. On reflection, a header may have been the right choice perhaps? Blackburn were not really offering much but out of nowhere; they nearly got an unlikely goal. Brittain’s cross-shot had to be dealt with by Davies and he did well to flick the ball behind. The first half ended with Rovers knowing that results elsewhere meant they were still very much in with a chance of making the playoffs.



The second half began with a more open feel and started to see gaps appearing. Peck had a shot blocked and then Hamer and O’Hare forced an opening that led to a corner, as United continued to look the more likely. However, after an attack broke down, Blackburn broke well at pace and had men over. Hedges found Brittain, whom in turn, fed OHASHI and his shot clipped Holding and went past Davies and there was jubilation in the away end. The ‘As its stands’ table had Rovers into 6th place with Bristol City trailing at home to Preston.



United did respond though only 9 minutes later as Hamer sent over a dangerous cross after a first attack had not been cleared. Holding met it and guided it perfectly into the path of his fellow centre half AHMEDHODZIC who toe poked home from close range. The Rovers fans’ glee was silenced quickly and just like that, they were out of the top 6, almost as quickly as they went into it!



The game now saw a flurry of chances with Brewster and Seriki on for the home side for Hamer and Gilchrist and Kargbo on for Hedges for the Lancastrians, with the latter looking like a bad injury as he could not put any weight on the ball as he left the field. United were moving the ball well through the central area and Brewster, now captain, was using the ball well and a few nice flicks saw half chances. O’Hare then worked some space with Brooks and the latter was starting to now attack his man.

Peck had another effort blocked, as did O’Hare and then a dreadful miss after brilliant work from Brooks saw the chance teed up via O’Hare for Cannon but he blazed over with the goal at his mercy.

Dennis and Gueye replaced Cantwell and Dolan for Rovers and One was on for Cannon for the home side. Soon after it was Forshaw and Woodrow for Travis and Tronstad. Davies then replaced Souza and it was clear Wilder now wanted to protect key players. Dolan offered a riposte with a long-range effort and Davies made a meal out of it, gathering at the second attempt. Blackburn had heard that Bristol City were now level but knew they still only needed another goal, if results stayed the game but were not exactly creating chance after chance. Brewster played in O’Hare who had a shot saved before O’Hare again did well and linked with Brooks but the ball was bundled behind



Burrows came on for McCallum as the game entered the final 5 minutes. Seriki went down after a challenge and was in some distress and had to go off holding his arm seemingly and it looked a really bad one as he was strapped up. One was in but he was selfish with men over and took the shot rather than a pass that may have led to the winner before Burrows conceded an unnecessary corner. Toth was up for this and a subsequent corner, but Dennis’ header well wide was the closest they got and United actually ended up on the attack to close the 8 (10 were played actually) additional minutes of time. The final whistle went and Blackburn players slumped to their knees whilst for United, attentions turn to the playoffs beginning on Thursday.



United – It was quite a fun game. Thought first half was bit of a grueller and little happened but we did play some decent stuff at times, if a little slow. Hamer was our main architect and looking to link with others but there were few chances until Cannon had the shot saved but Hamer should have scored from the Brooks cross. We struggled to get much going down the sides but attacked well down the middle – we have not see that and we did have some joy with this approach. Thought Blackburn looked poor and created very little other than the cross shot and trying to con the ref with penalties. I thought Hamer got little protection form a poor ref and I would have considered taking him off at half time to protect him – but he did go off before any damage could be done. I think Blackburn just wanted to be cautious but we had a few chances to be ahead so it was a risky tactic. WE had loads of ball but both teams were poor in possession and gave it away a lot but we looked a better side technically and had more creativity. They did then suddenly score out of nothing – decent break and finish – if deflected. After this though we scored not long after. Then for the final 30 minutes, it was entertaining. They sort of left gaps but not sure they had lots of men forward or created much either – they seemed caught in two minds. They threw subs on and the fans encouraged them to come forward but they looked leggy and we finished the stronger and had so many chances really. Cannon, O’Hare, One and a few others really should have got us a few goals. Cannon’s miss was appalling – he had been ok up to then too. It was odd, as we watched a timid and poor Blackburn side, that you thought we would beat over a two-legged playoff, you reckon so in your head you think losing a goal would maybe not the worst thing – but players do not think like that and even as a fan, you want to win of course. IF they had scored, I would not have been devastated but then they may have gone into the playoffs on a high. In the end, they had a few corners and tried to find something but never really had a clear chance – at least in comparison to the ones we created.



United should have won. The performance was better in terms of us creating things and the way we attacked but we had some vulnerabilities too at the back. I was pleased we saw O’Hare have a really good game and Brooks finished the game well – showing he could be a viable option from the bench. We showed flashes of at least some attacking play that saw chances created. The Seriki injury was a sour note of course. In terms of the week, we end the season in better form at least. Bristol City were better than us over both games I have to admit but they limped in (pitch invasion seemed a bit embarrassing and should be motivation – odd quirk they only got in because of us getting that leveller!). I think and hope we will play better against them. The team picks itself I think for 9 positions – Cooper, Choudhury, Burrows, Anel, Souza, Peck, O’Hare, Hamer and Campbell I reckon? Then it will be Holding or Robinson. I would pick the former – Wilder won’t sadly. He will then make the change for the second leg if it does not go well but needs to do it now. Not sure both were great today but feel better and less panicky with Holding there. The other picks will be Rak Sakyi or Brereton Diaz. I feel he may go for the latter away and then the former at home. I’d pick JRS as he at least keeps the defence back.



Am I confident? Nope. We always blow the playoffs somehow (50% of the 8 ties where the final was at Wembley/Cardiff, ee have got through – Bristol City of course in 1988 was not to get to Wembley) and you feel we might never win them (surely we will). However, not sure any of the other three are that great. I was glad to avoid Coventry – they are either really poor or blow teams away but will be tough at home and can score goals. Sunderland have been on wretched form but have shown they have pace/attacking threats. I am ok with who we play but we must ensure we start well, defend properly, and win the midfield battle. We cannot be passive and have to ensure that we do not play to score first rather than sit back. We will see. As it stands, I still think Coventry weirdly might be the team that goes up but we just need a few big games from our creative talents and Souza to be the player he can be to control midfield. We cannot say we go into this as underdogs and probably the bookies favourites but have to put in three good performances. Let’s see how Wilder and the players present and prove that they have been the third best team. Nervy times!

I hope you’re right about the team picking itself for 9 positions but unfortunately I would not rule out seeing Brewster instead of O’Hare, which would be a retrograde step.

Like Clough in 2014-5, Wilder has no idea what his best XI is despite the fact that the regular season is over.