LouTheBlade
Active Member
Without getting carried away I think the performance at St James’ was a pretty good indication of where we are in terms of the squad at the moment. United played quite well for large parts of the first half, particularly in midfield where I thought we started very brightly and closed the ball down well. Sadly though, we showed once again that we lack any sort of incisiveness and invention in the final third and managed to score a goal from an opportunistic flick. We also looked very naive defensively at times and with Newcastle’s attacking quality, they were always likely to find it easy getting in behind us.
I think the game showed our qualities and inadequacies quite clearly and I am in no doubt now as to which players I would keep and which ones I would move on. Unfortunately KB is unlikely to see it the same way as the average fan (i.e. me) but opinion is what makes football so interesting. I took many positives from that game but there were also some glaring issues that stick out in showing that some players just simply aren’t good enough to get us where we want to be. Of the players we currently have at the club I would do my utmost to keep the following;
Paddy Kenny
Best Goalkeeper in the Championship on his day, a true Blade.
Mikhel Aksalu
I would like to see him play before making a judgment.
Derek Geary
There is always room for someone like Del, but he has to prove his fitness.
Nyron Nosworthy
Opinions are divided on him but I think he’s great. He has entertainment value and he’s shown good commitment as a loanee. He would become a Blades favourite.
Chris Morgan
Makes some daft decisions at times but a great captain and we miss his presence when he doesn’t play.
Kyle Bartley
I know this lad had a shocker against Scunny and after starting well has looked a little naive; but he has some terrific attributes and will become a good centre half with experience IMO. We should try and get him on a season long loan if we can.
Gary Naysmith
I am under no illusions regarding his situation and he will probably be moved on because of his salary. If we can afford to keep him we should as Taylor and Stewart should be moved on IMO.
Lee Williamson
Quality player, but should be deployed as a central midfielder and not as a wide player.
James Harper
He blows hot and cold. Has been slightly disappointing considering his pedigree but he has great experience and can do something unique to our squad. He can pass the ball.
Nick Montgomery
Frustrates the bollocks off me and he was diabolical at St James’ but there will be games where he can be used effectively. Very committed ball winner as we all know. I would keep him for now.
Kyel Reid
Hardly seen him play and he is in great form for Charlton. If we can get him settled he would be a good squad player.
Darius Henderson
Some fans don’t like him and he can be a daft sod at times but if we can keep him fit and calm his temper he is a good player to have. He gives us a powerful presence up top.
Richard Cresswell
He is simply our most effective player at the moment. A hard working, honest guy. He will be a mainstay next season.
Billy Sharp
Keep if Blackwell goes. Sell if Blackwell stays.
Jamie Ward
Our best player. Enough said.
Any players not mentioned above should be moved on IMO. Either because I believe them to be over the hill or not good enough. I have heard of a few names mentioned as possible signings, most recently Phil Bardsley this morning but I would like to hear the opinions of fellow Blades. Who would you like to see at the club???
I think the game showed our qualities and inadequacies quite clearly and I am in no doubt now as to which players I would keep and which ones I would move on. Unfortunately KB is unlikely to see it the same way as the average fan (i.e. me) but opinion is what makes football so interesting. I took many positives from that game but there were also some glaring issues that stick out in showing that some players just simply aren’t good enough to get us where we want to be. Of the players we currently have at the club I would do my utmost to keep the following;
Paddy Kenny
Best Goalkeeper in the Championship on his day, a true Blade.
Mikhel Aksalu
I would like to see him play before making a judgment.
Derek Geary
There is always room for someone like Del, but he has to prove his fitness.
Nyron Nosworthy
Opinions are divided on him but I think he’s great. He has entertainment value and he’s shown good commitment as a loanee. He would become a Blades favourite.
Chris Morgan
Makes some daft decisions at times but a great captain and we miss his presence when he doesn’t play.
Kyle Bartley
I know this lad had a shocker against Scunny and after starting well has looked a little naive; but he has some terrific attributes and will become a good centre half with experience IMO. We should try and get him on a season long loan if we can.
Gary Naysmith
I am under no illusions regarding his situation and he will probably be moved on because of his salary. If we can afford to keep him we should as Taylor and Stewart should be moved on IMO.
Lee Williamson
Quality player, but should be deployed as a central midfielder and not as a wide player.
James Harper
He blows hot and cold. Has been slightly disappointing considering his pedigree but he has great experience and can do something unique to our squad. He can pass the ball.
Nick Montgomery
Frustrates the bollocks off me and he was diabolical at St James’ but there will be games where he can be used effectively. Very committed ball winner as we all know. I would keep him for now.
Kyel Reid
Hardly seen him play and he is in great form for Charlton. If we can get him settled he would be a good squad player.
Darius Henderson
Some fans don’t like him and he can be a daft sod at times but if we can keep him fit and calm his temper he is a good player to have. He gives us a powerful presence up top.
Richard Cresswell
He is simply our most effective player at the moment. A hard working, honest guy. He will be a mainstay next season.
Billy Sharp
Keep if Blackwell goes. Sell if Blackwell stays.
Jamie Ward
Our best player. Enough said.
Any players not mentioned above should be moved on IMO. Either because I believe them to be over the hill or not good enough. I have heard of a few names mentioned as possible signings, most recently Phil Bardsley this morning but I would like to hear the opinions of fellow Blades. Who would you like to see at the club???
someone had to say it. Although Worksop did say it first. I can't see it personally. He will want too much money. I think Pompey will keep him for their CCC campaign anyway. Time and time again we have suggested signing him back over the last few years. I started to think that the older he got, the less appealing it seemed.....
