blader
Well-Known Member
For those of you interested in this sort of thing:
Notts fans on JCR:
"Slightly disappointed, but that's all. He was poor at best for eighteen months, albeit superb at the end of last season. Considering his age, too, he wasn't worth really pushing the boat out for. Good luck to him, though, always put the effort in."
"Disappointed if both he and Sheehan go to Sheff U. I'd be more disappointed if I was a Blades fan though. These were standout players in a sh!t team last year, and would expect to be strictly bench material for a side pushing for promotion."
"not that bothered to be honest. yes he played well towards the end of the season but prior was pretty poor."
"He was a decent player in a crap side"
"This is a big loss in my opinion."
"In terms of Sheff Utd, it's a very peculiar signing indeed for a team trying to go for automatic promotion."
"I think Sheffield United have a bargain"
"he was blistering for a couple of months. A couple of months in 2 years isn't really good enough though."
"Not a great signing for them IMHO and that's honestly not sour grapes."
"JCR is too greedy on the ball so i'm sure we can replace them."
"He ran around a lot, worked hard and had little end product for most of his time at Notts."
"A shocking loss. I reckon JCR's name was pencilled in for next season and Derry & Abbott will be very disappointed"
Livi fans on McNulty:
"It's probably time for him to get a fresh challenge. Good luck to him wherever he ends up. He has done well for Livi."
"IMO he still has a lot of maturing to do before he makes it at a higher level. Never quite became the goal machine he was tipped to be during his u-19 career here."
"Def has ability but just doesn't score as much as you'd expect and does it in fits and starts."
"been a good player for us and we'll miss him."
"Sad to see him go but there was no chance of us keeping a hold of him, he'll be really hard to replace."
"I think, for his own good, he's got to go this summer. Don't get me wrong, I'd love to keep him but if he doesn't bang them in next season, he'd mayeb miss the chance for a decent move. Lyle Taylor was on-loan at Partick this season from Sheff Utd and if McNulty went down there and taylor returns too, could see those two forming a fantastic partnership with Scougall in behind."
"Sparky's got an undoubted natural goalscoring talent - the type of player who can be out of a game for most of the 90 minutes then bang you in a winning goal out of nowhere (much like Saturday actually!).
He had a bit of an off spell around about the time he went on trial at Derby but it seems that he's got back to knuckling down and it's shown in his performances - certainly no surprise to see him up the top of the goalscoring charts in the league."
Notts fans on JCR:
"Slightly disappointed, but that's all. He was poor at best for eighteen months, albeit superb at the end of last season. Considering his age, too, he wasn't worth really pushing the boat out for. Good luck to him, though, always put the effort in."
"Disappointed if both he and Sheehan go to Sheff U. I'd be more disappointed if I was a Blades fan though. These were standout players in a sh!t team last year, and would expect to be strictly bench material for a side pushing for promotion."
"not that bothered to be honest. yes he played well towards the end of the season but prior was pretty poor."
"He was a decent player in a crap side"
"This is a big loss in my opinion."
"In terms of Sheff Utd, it's a very peculiar signing indeed for a team trying to go for automatic promotion."
"I think Sheffield United have a bargain"
"he was blistering for a couple of months. A couple of months in 2 years isn't really good enough though."
"Not a great signing for them IMHO and that's honestly not sour grapes."
"JCR is too greedy on the ball so i'm sure we can replace them."
"He ran around a lot, worked hard and had little end product for most of his time at Notts."
"A shocking loss. I reckon JCR's name was pencilled in for next season and Derry & Abbott will be very disappointed"
Livi fans on McNulty:
"It's probably time for him to get a fresh challenge. Good luck to him wherever he ends up. He has done well for Livi."
"IMO he still has a lot of maturing to do before he makes it at a higher level. Never quite became the goal machine he was tipped to be during his u-19 career here."
"Def has ability but just doesn't score as much as you'd expect and does it in fits and starts."
"been a good player for us and we'll miss him."
"Sad to see him go but there was no chance of us keeping a hold of him, he'll be really hard to replace."
"I think, for his own good, he's got to go this summer. Don't get me wrong, I'd love to keep him but if he doesn't bang them in next season, he'd mayeb miss the chance for a decent move. Lyle Taylor was on-loan at Partick this season from Sheff Utd and if McNulty went down there and taylor returns too, could see those two forming a fantastic partnership with Scougall in behind."
"Sparky's got an undoubted natural goalscoring talent - the type of player who can be out of a game for most of the 90 minutes then bang you in a winning goal out of nowhere (much like Saturday actually!).
He had a bit of an off spell around about the time he went on trial at Derby but it seems that he's got back to knuckling down and it's shown in his performances - certainly no surprise to see him up the top of the goalscoring charts in the league."
