My take ...

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

pommpey

THE FUTURE ... AS IT USED TO BE
Joined
Dec 9, 2015
Messages
9,261
Reaction score
26,523
Location
South Coast
Great show, from everyone in fact. So pleased, not just for Wilder, but for the team and for us. We've suffered enough.

First half was Sheffield United of last season. Right the way across the team and the pitch, we were at them and moving forward. And that was right from the kick off, not ten minutes in. Come 20 minutes I was wondering when Newcastle were going to take the ball off us and then just pressure us into giving the game away, but we just didn't allow them that luxury. For once this season the defence looked like they knew where each other was and they played like an effective outfit, covering off, moving out of the backline and controlling their attacking forays. Okay, Newcastle got a decent cross in which they should have converted but really, the back three weren't under any pressure. And that's no reflection on how poor NUFC were - they do have capability up front. This also combined with surges up the wing and Ampadu seemed to play a lot wider and with more freedom that he has recently. NUFC tried to stick four out into the dead zone but were not sharp enough to stop Dids breaking through - the left side this time seemed a better prospect with Osborn so far advanced, Fleck now switched on and Ampadu providing the safety net and overload. Over the other side it was the same story too. We just didn't manage to get the luck or the break until Fraser got his second yellow - deservedly so.

Kinda knew Bruce would put the blockers up with 4-4-1 in the second half and for about twenty minutes I wasn't convinced we'd get the lucky break. We still seemed to dawdle in the wide areas despite having a heck of a lot of chances to cross. Down the wing, meet the block, back a bit, across the pitch, down the other wing, et cetera. Even when we hooked Burke and Basham, puzzling substitutes despite Basham having a below par game, we still seemed reluctant to tear their fucking throats out and leave them bleeding out. The midfield - for so long our painful weakness tonight was pretty bloody flawless save for one or two misplaced passes and the bit was evident that 'they want this'. Okay, they gave us a lot of time on the ball but big deal. It's up to us to exploit weaknesses like that. The only thing that worried me was either a Ramsdale fuck up (or dropped catch) or a boot down the pitch which beats the back four, as it was by then.

After we scored however we seemed to shit a brick a bit and you could see the team panicking a bit when they brought Carrol on. It was as if we were expecting them to score, or even win. The belief for a bit seemed to be ebbing out somewhat, almost 'fuck me, we are in front. We must give the game back to them'. Norwood makes a daft cross field pass and puts us in trouble and suddenly we are defending and losing the plot. But we survived. And I'm so fucking glad. Usually we just fold. Tonight, we didn't.

Ramsdale 7/10: A clean sheet. Congratulations feller, you have deserved it, however, fucking communicate with your left side back four at all times as to where the fuck you are if the ball is approaching him. Ramsdale was 50% responsible for what would have been the most embarrassing fuck up in our history. The glee on his face when he caught that tame free kick at the end said it all. Long may it continue.
Bogle 7/10: Drops a point for the other 50% for the above, but overall a pretty fucking good outing. George Baldock needs to get fit and get fighting for his place back because Bogle is impressive and developing. Unlucky not to score again.
Basham 5/10: Fragile tonight and for two matches running, seemed to be flagging a bit. C'mon Bash. You're better than this.
Egan 8/10: Fucking monumental. A real rock at the back and linked well with Norwood and Ampadu. Some good interceptions and blocks, and positionally good.
Ampadu 7.5/10: Motored really well in the first half and looked like he wanted his shirt for once.
Osborn 8/10: Pleasing outing and he got very involved down the flank and a simply excellet block in the first half
Lundstram 7/10: One of his best games for a long while in a United shirt. He actually looked like he wanted the game tonight, and showed pleasing levels of energy and commitment
Norwood 2/10: Just kidding! 7.5/10: Would have got half a point more save for that daft pass but tonight he was a damned sight better than any performance for about a year or so. His first two corners were decent balls into the danger area, he worked fucking hard in a largely empty midfield linking and passing and got stuck in without his usual desperate silliness. Spread the ball well left and right and even won a few aerial challenges.
Fleck 6.5/10: A vast improvement on recent outings. Did fairly well out wide and linking when Wilder changed to 4-3-1-2 and showed better composure but still naps a bit in possession and gets his pocket picked
McGoldrick 8/10: Great game. Again, involved in everything, if not attracting players to him to stop playing then showing for the ball and being generally a pain in the arse for the opposition midfield and defence. Would have loved to have seen him lift that ball up into the far top corner instead of give the keeper a decent save
Burke 7/10: What a pest, but again, needs shooting practice. That clearance he blocked with the rear of his thigh in the first half and hardly flinched - that'll smart tomorrow morning. But that was typical of his 'never give up' game. He needs a PL goal

Brewster 7/10: A much better game although the Geordies did give him loads of room to run at them. So unlucky with the post hit. Looks sharper and more hungry.
Sharp 6/10: Well fought for and taken penalty, but fuck me Billy. What the fuck are you doing putting your studs down a player's ankle? So lucky not to be redded. He has that in him. He did it v Scumpton last season at BDTBL and needs to fucking stop it. But he won us the game.
Jagielka n/a:

Wilder 9/10: Well done boss and congratulations on your win. Sometimes can be difficult to play against ten men and especially a Bruce outfit as he tends to have some solution which opens us up. But tonight CW had the fellers fired up and playing 2019-20 football, at last. It was a pleasing, sometimes nervy game, but at last we have aclean sheet and a win. Big deal if its just 1-0 and against ten men. We got away with a red card and they didn't - which makes a fucking change.

Europe back on, then?

pommpey
 

Does anyone not see what I see in Lundstram? That he continually doesn’t think ‘forward first’ then goes sideways if nothings on? He is so negative in his passing and his body is square on constantly. He’s our most athletic midfielder and an essential cog if we want to move up the pitch quickly when countering but he never looks forward. I wish we could exchange Lunnys athleticism with Bash’s ability to see gaps and run through them in control of the ball.

agree with everything else.
 
Great report Pommpey, lots of positives. Encouraging signs from Fleck, but I do think some have exaggerated his return to form and how effective he was tonight.
 
Bit generous on Norwood as he could have cost us the game with that sloppy bit of play which turned the possession over. But apart from that he was a lot better.

Thought Bash should have stayed on as that sub stunted our momentum a bit.

I agree that Sharp was very lucky not to get a red card. His penalty more than made up for that though.

Thought Burke did well and could have had a couple of goals, granted it's what makes the difference but that's the only side of his game that has been lacking.
 
Excellent write up as usual, always say it as you see it, even if some don’t like what they’ve seen in the last 17 games/write ups 😉

A good observation about the panic that set in after we went 1-0 up ! Understandable of course and hopefully, with the monkey off our back in the league, we’ll remain a bit more composed next time we are in front.
 

I wondered what you'd write Pommps. Great report to follow a performance which made me wonder what's been happening for 7 months- it's like they've been in some sort of induced coma then suddenly woken up. Osborn looked every inch a PL player. I have never seen Ramsdale smile but the huge grin tonight said it all. We wanted a bit of fight but what we got was actually pretty good football. Bizarre but very welcome!!
 
Well said!

We have to remember that they’re not robots, and I can forgive them for being nervy at 1-0, especially after Brighton, Leicester etc. I felt sick watching it at home, so who knows what it must be like when your career is potentially at stake. Hopefully that’s it out of their system now, and they’ll have last season’s belief when we lead game.
 
What a relief... to see a positive pommpey :)

As for Ramsdale's part in the potential last second feck-up, zero blame. His call was so loud for Bogle to leave it to him that it was probably heard at Hunter's Bar.

Bogle (along with Burke) has been one of our few successes this season prior to last night, so he gets a pass.

Newcastle, though, were perfect opposition, entirely passive from the start. A pity we couldn't have played them before now.
 
A first win of the season and you give Norwood more than two out of ten! What an historic day this is for United!! 😂
 
It was ace, last night, we played like we did last season, moving forward with pace, playing give and go football and creating chances ( but no taking them)
Then the tension after we scored waiting for the inevitable equaliser from an Andy Carroll header in the 4th minute of injury time
But we did it, such a relief, the next batch of games are now very tough, but it’s just feels great to get the win at long last
 
Newcastle, though, were perfect opposition, entirely passive from the start. A pity we couldn't have played them before now.

As has been asked elsewhere: how on Earth do they have 19 points?!? It was the most negative performance I've seen since the Pigs came to Bramall Lane (swap Carroll for Nuhiu and it was a carbon copy). At least then we were flying, and the Pigs were desperate to salvage some pride. I'm a rare person who actually rates Steve Bruce, but I'm struggling to see what his plan was yesterday.
 
however, fucking communicate with your left side back four at all times as to where the fuck you are if the ball is approaching him. Ramsdale was 50% responsible for what would have been the most embarrassing fuck up in our history.

Having watched it again, Ramsdale is 90% at fault. He's the one who can see what is happening, and he's the one who took up the stranger position, so he HAS to yell out what he's doing. It's possible that he did, and that Bogle ignored him of course. No harm done though :oops: :rolleyes:
 
Having watched it again, Ramsdale is 90% at fault. He's the one who can see what is happening, and he's the one who took up the stranger position, so he HAS to yell out what he's doing. It's possible that he did, and that Bogle ignored him of course. No harm done though :oops: :rolleyes:
Why was it a strange position, he's claiming the ball through.
 
Having watched it again, Ramsdale is 90% at fault. He's the one who can see what is happening, and he's the one who took up the stranger position, so he HAS to yell out what he's doing. It's possible that he did, and that Bogle ignored him of course. No harm done though :oops: :rolleyes:
I think the issue was they were both shitting themselves, understandably, and nearly made me join in at the time.
 
As has been asked elsewhere: how on Earth do they have 19 points?!? It was the most negative performance I've seen since the Pigs came to Bramall Lane (swap Carroll for Nuhiu and it was a carbon copy). At least then we were flying, and the Pigs were desperate to salvage some pride. I'm a rare person who actually rates Steve Bruce, but I'm struggling to see what his plan was yesterday.
 
It’s how they play every week and they are getting massive criticism from the Newcastle fans
Home or away defend deep and in numbers hoping not to concede and ultimately look to nick a goal, that basically is their plan every week
 
It’s how they play every week and they are getting massive criticism from the Newcastle fans
Home or away defend deep and in numbers hoping not to concede and ultimately look to nick a goal, that basically is their plan every week
They normally have almiron or saint maximan to stretch the oppo with their pace, but none of that yesterday.
 

I can only go on what I heard on Radio Sheff, and the clips on SSN.

To me, this was night and day compared to this seasons performances, a flashback to last season.

Our pen, I thought was a tad fortunate. Looked to me like Billy gave the guy a bit of a nudge (not a foul just a nudge) and the guy went into the ball, but hey we'll take it.

As an ex keeper myself, thats Ramsdale's ball and if he didn't shout (I'm not sure whether he did or didn't) then he should have. But a clean sheet, lets hope that gives the lad a boost.

A win at last, thank fuck :)
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom