James “Jimmy” Harrop (dob 05/02/1884 – 25/05/1954) – Aston Villa 1912 – 1921 Sheffield United 1921 – 1922
Derek “Doc” Pace (dob 11/03/1932) : Aston Villa 1950 – 1957 Sheffield United 1957 – 1964
Ian “Chico” Hamilton (dob 31/10/1950): Aston Villa 1969 – 1976 Sheffield United 1976 – 1978
Trevor Hockey (dob 01/05/1943 – 01/04/1987): Sheffield United 1971 – 1973 Aston Villa 1973 – 1974
Gordon Cowans (dob 27/10/1958): Aston Villa 1976 – 1985 1988 – 1991 1993 – 1994 Sheffield United 1995 – 1996
Peter Withe (dob 30/08/1951): Aston Villa 1980 – 1985 Sheffield United 1985 – 1989
Kevin Gage (dob 21/04/1964): Aston Villa 1987 – 1991 Sheffield United 1991 – 1996
Paul McGrath (dob 04/12/1959): Aston Villa 1989 – 1996 Sheffield United 1997 – 1998
Dean Saunders (dob 21/06/1964): Aston Villa 1992 – 1995 Sheffield United 1997 – 1998
Carl Tiler (dob 11/02/1970): Aston Villa 1995 – 1997 Sheffield United 1997
Ugo Ehiogu (dob 03/11/1972 – 21/04/2017): Aston Villa 1991 – 2000 Sheffield United 2008 – 2009
Lee Hendrie (dob 18/05/1977): Aston Villa 1994 – 2007 Sheffield United 2007 – 2009
Alan Wright (dob 28/09/1971): Aston Villa 1995 – 2003 Sheffield United 2003 loan – 2007
Matt Lowton (dob 09/06/1989): Sheffield United 2007 – 2012 Aston Villa 2012 – 2015
Mark Bunn (dob 16/11/1984): Sheffield United loan 2009 – 2010 Aston Villa 2015 – 2019
Enda Stevens (dob 09/07/1990): Aston Villa 2012 – 2015 Sheffield United 2017 –
Samir Carruthers (dob 04/04/1993): Aston Villa 2012 – 2014 Sheffield United 2017 – 2019
Callum Robinson (dob 02/02/1995): Aston Villa 2013 – 2016 Sheffield United 2019 –