Madine - did you overreact?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Did you overreact?

  • Fuck yeah, shag me Gary

    Votes: 47 24.0%

  • Yep

    Votes: 63 32.1%

  • Jury’s out

    Votes: 32 16.3%

  • No he’s still a nobhead

    Votes: 54 27.6%
  • Total voters
    196
Akinbiyi said:
He’s contributed more than enough to ask people if they over reacted when they literally hoping he failed.
Click to expand...
The people you say 'over reacted' were doing so because of Madine's history of violence not his ability or lack of match fitness. Anybody with an ounce of integrity have stuck to their principles that they do not want such a person representing Sheffield United; that it may appear to have gone quiet is that irrespective of what we want he is now representing our club so the mature position is to just accept it and not stir the pot, I'm sorry you aren't able to do this.
 

Think I need to apologise to this old friend who happens to be a Wednesday fan.

When we were about to sign him he said about Madine.

‘He should be a good fit for your teem because he’s like McGoldrick, very good at holding the ball and laying it off”
Said ‘like McGoldrick he’s not generally a goal scorer but he’s a decent passer and will set up chances for Sharp”.

When he said Madine played in a similiar fashion to McGoldrick I almost burst out laughing assuming he can’t have ever seen McG play.
I suppose it was his way of saying Madine isn’t just “a big lump who can head a ball”, he actually has decent ability to play in a passing team. To be fair he is better on the ball than I expected, just shows how playing for Bolton and Cardiff made him play like a big lump,
 
Sheffsteel said:
Not bothered about the morality of players because I don’t need to socialise with them and be a friend
Also there’s a potential to be an hypocrital because many players have done immoral things in their past.
Try not to mix politics with supporting my club.
Click to expand...

You may not be bothered about morality but others are and it's nothing to do with being someone's friend. The "other players have done immoral things" is along the lines of the "everyone's done the same as Ched on a night out" bollocks. The number of players convicted for assaulting someone is very, very low.
And having morals and standards is not "politics" and it's not just your club.

He's proved to be a reasonable signing on his limited showings so far; although I am still worried that we are going to change our style of play too much to suit him, it doesn't seem to have happened that much so far. People wanting a "plan B" style of play seem to have been satisfied, nonetheless.
None of that alters the unhappiness a lot of people have at him representing the club. He needs to be whiter than white off field whilst he's with us (though to be fair, I would hope all players behave decently whilst at the club).
 
Akinbiyi said:
Goals will come but they’re not as important as he brings so much to the attack and allows others the space to score. He’s been desperately unlucky not to score with the effort McGoldrick turned in from offside against Boro and hitting the inside of the post for Billy’s 2nd at Villa.
Click to expand...

Goals will come? We will see.

They are not as important as what he brings to the attack? Nonsense. Nothing is more important. If we end up using Madine all of the time in preference to McGoldrick and he never scores, we are going to lose points. Bringing things to the attack will only get you so far, unless Billy is going to keep scoring 6 goals every 4 games.
 
Hamburg Blade said:
You may not be bothered about morality but others are and it's nothing to do with being someone's friend. The "other players have done immoral things" is along the lines of the "everyone's done the same as Ched on a night out" bollocks. The number of players convicted for assaulting someone is very, very low.
And having morals and standards is not "politics" and it's not just your club.

He's proved to be a reasonable signing on his limited showings so far; although I am still worried that we are going to change our style of play too much to suit him, it doesn't seem to have happened that much so far. People wanting a "plan B" style of play seem to have been satisfied, nonetheless.
None of that alters the unhappiness a lot of people have at him representing the club. He needs to be whiter than white off field whilst he's with us (though to be fair, I would hope all players behave decently whilst at the club).
Click to expand...

Appreciate where your coming from.
Doubt others have done what Ched has done but some will be morally worse and some morally better but still immoral.
Where do you draw the line? Especially when you often judging using newspaper reports that are renowned for being sensationalist and manipulative.

Personally I class what John Terry did as morally worse, sleeping with your colleagues/ friends wife, premeditated and continuous destroying life’s at home and in the workplace. John Terry sounds a deceitful nasty piece of work, but the reports may be misleading and he may be a nice guy in real life.

I believe that Messi and Mourinho have been done for tax evasion and I believe both had suspended prison sentences.
Also believe the club hero TC was in court for domestic violence against his ex wife many decades ago.
Society should be about trusting the law, punishing that person, then allow that person to learn from mistakes and get on with their lives. Of course everyone is entitled to a personal boycott for whatever reason.
 
Revolution said:
Goals will come? We will see.

They are not as important as what he brings to the attack? Nonsense. Nothing is more important. If we end up using Madine all of the time in preference to McGoldrick and he never scores, we are going to lose points. Bringing things to the attack will only get you so far, unless Billy is going to keep scoring 6 goals every 4 games.
Click to expand...
It’s not nonsense in the slightest. We’ve scored 6 goals in 3 games with Madine on the pitch. He causes havoc in the opposition area which other players will profit from every time.
 
Sheffsteel said:
Appreciate where your coming from.
Doubt others have done what Ched has done but some will be morally worse and some morally better but still immoral.
Where do you draw the line? Especially when you often judging using newspaper reports that are renowned for being sensationalist and manipulative.

Personally I class what John Terry did as morally worse, sleeping with your colleagues/ friends wife, premeditated and continuous destroying life’s at home and in the workplace. John Terry sounds a deceitful nasty piece of work, but the reports may be misleading and he may be a nice guy in real life.

I believe that Messi and Mourinho have been done for tax evasion and I believe both had suspended prison sentences.
Also believe the club hero TC was in court for domestic violence against his ex wife many decades ago.
Society should be about trusting the law, punishing that person, then allow that person to learn from mistakes and get on with their lives. Of course everyone is entitled to a personal boycott for whatever reason.
Click to expand...
It isn't about trusting the media or listening to rumours though. There are criminal convictions.
Where do you draw the line? Well that's a personal opinion, but I think it is very wrong to sneer at people who have chosen to have a moral stance, which is what this thread does.
@8blade sums it up perfectly with this:
8lade said:
The people you say 'over reacted' were doing so because of Madine's history of violence not his ability or lack of match fitness. Anybody with an ounce of integrity have stuck to their principles that they do not want such a person representing Sheffield United; that it may appear to have gone quiet is that irrespective of what we want he is now representing our club so the mature position is to just accept it and not stir the pot, I'm sorry you aren't able to do this.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't have signed him, but now he's here, I'm prepared to sit back and let him get on with it. He'll get applause from me for anything he achieves for us, but it'll take a while and a fair bit on his behalf for me to be happy about his presence. The whole "he's served his time" argument has validity, but is also a grey area. It's not as if it's a one-off mistake from him - and I'm sure there are plenty of situations where people wouldn't apply such a forgiving attitude in their own lives/situations. On top of that, football is different to, say, working as a joiner at a building firm. You take the big bucks, you should have to take on the responsibilites.
I hope he continues to show his worth, because if he doesn't it will cost us points.
 
Akinbiyi said:
It’s not nonsense in the slightest. We’ve scored 6 goals in 3 games with Madine on the pitch. He causes havoc in the opposition area which other players will profit from every time.
Click to expand...

We've scored 5 in 5 games when he was on the field.

He assisted 2 of them.
 
Revolution said:
We've scored 5 in 5 games when he was on the field.

He assisted 2 of them.
Click to expand...
Conveniently bringing in the Swansea and Bolton games where he had 10/15 minutes respectively and not a smidge of a chance.

If you want to go on minutes he's had about 200 minutes and in that time we've scored sorry, yes, 5 goals. Him assisting 2. He also should've had 2 penalties against Boro.
Quite the impact if you ask me. Feel free to disagree but you're wrong and the management clearly think so too.
 
Akinbiyi said:
Conveniently bringing in the Swansea and Bolton games where he had 10/15 minutes respectively and not a smidge of a chance.

If you want to go on minutes he's had about 200 minutes and in that time we've scored sorry, yes, 5 goals. Him assisting 2. He also should've had 2 penalties against Boro.
Quite the impact if you ask me. Feel free to disagree but you're wrong and the management clearly think so too.
Click to expand...
One of these assists is him missing the goal. I don't like this "assist" thing, which seems to have been nicked from ice hockey, because it's another misleading statistic. An incisive through ball or cross is what I would term an "assist". Missing the goal but having another team mate pounce on the rebound is great in the grand scheme of things, but attributing an "assist" to someone in those circumstances is, as I say, misleading.
That's not a criticism of Madine, who went for goal, which I would expect from a striker, but it's nonsense to attribute it to Madine as some sort of award.
 
He’s had a decent start but he hasn’t done that well already that he will have already played his part by the seasons end, I expect much more from a striker for that to happen.

I can almost guarantee that some will laud Madine at the end of the season no matter what he does and forget about Goldy and Sharps’ contribution, it’s the way of the world unfortunately.
 
Akinbiyi said:
I can honestly say I said he’d be very good. Had a few arguments about it in my previous guise... ooo mysterious.

He’s settled in now and he’s contributed a fair amount. We’ve seen what he’s about so it’s time to ask the question.

He’s even better than I thought he was, both aerially and technically. He causes absolute chaos and he must be the best targetman in the division. Pisses all over Hugill today.

If we do the unthinkable Gary will have played his part, he’s a huge part of our final stretch now.
Click to expand...

Quite right.

He’s a better footballer than I gave him credit for. I was put off by his past behaviour and didn’t think I’d acknowledge his efforts at all. But I’ve been shouting “Well played” and “Well done” to him. And I don’t think I’ll be able to stop myself cheering when he scores. I may try to suppress it, but last time I did that it just stored up inside me and came out as a huge fart at the Vicars garden party the next day.
 
wizadry said:
He’s had a decent start but he hasn’t done that well already that he will have already played his part by the seasons end, I expect much more from a striker for that to happen.

I can almost guarantee that some will laud Madine at the end of the season no matter what he does and forget about Goldy and Sharps’ contribution, it’s the way of the world unfortunately.
Click to expand...
Second paragraph a very strange effort.
Let go of the hatred mate, not necessary.
 
wizadry said:
He’s had a decent start but he hasn’t done that well already that he will have already played his part by the seasons end, I expect much more from a striker for that to happen.

I can almost guarantee that some will laud Madine at the end of the season no matter what he does and forget about Goldy and Sharps’ contribution, it’s the way of the world unfortunately.
Click to expand...
No chance
 

Revolution said:
Goals will come? We will see.

They are not as important as what he brings to the attack? Nonsense. Nothing is more important. If we end up using Madine all of the time in preference to McGoldrick and he never scores, we are going to lose points. Bringing things to the attack will only get you so far, unless Billy is going to keep scoring 6 goals every 4 games.
Click to expand...
Our top scorer in the 2005-06 promotion season scored just 11 goals.

Madine takes the pressure off the other strikers and this will help the team to score more goals.
 
LSF said:
Second paragraph a very strange effort.
Let go of the hatred mate, not necessary.
Click to expand...
No hatred from me mate, we’ll wait and see and I’m sure I’ll be able to produce a post or two at the seasons end.

I didn’t want us to sign him as I thought he was shit before he came here but he’s had a decent start, no more no less, let’s see how it pans out from here on in.

I will state beyond doubt that I want the Blades to do very well indeed as I’m sure you know and if he contributes then he contributes but I won’t be told by anyone on here what’s necessary or not when it isn’t hatred, it’s more a realistic post on someone who’s played a handful of minutes in the context of things.

Anyone would think we were shit before he came in from some of the things you read on here, I won’t listen or read that bollocks or be influenced by the agenda some like to drive on social media.
 
Silent Blade said:
Our top scorer in the 2005-06 promotion season scored just 11 goals.

Madine takes the pressure off the other strikers and this will help the team to score more goals.
Click to expand...

That's right. He did that with 2 other forwards scoring 9 goals or more and Jags and Ifill scoring 17 between them. The striker goals are there this year but the midfield goals are not. If Madine is to play instead of McGoldrick, he needs to score like him.

Wilder understands this. 2 years ago Wilder had Hanson in the side but then dropped him for Clarke. One of the reasons for this was Hansons lack of goals. So it will go with Madine. He's come in at a tough time and done well, but if he doesn't score he'll be in the bench more often than not.
 
Yellarbellyblade said:
Heard he was extremely right footed and wouldn’t ever use the left. A bit of a loud mouth twat too with some very unpleasant off field behaviour. Makes Madine look a candidate for sainthood.
Click to expand...

He also had a very good attack up front with one outstanding forward esp in warmer weather, that is until he met our Monty in the midfield who put him into row Z.......:)
 
Akinbiyi said:
Conveniently bringing in the Swansea and Bolton games where he had 10/15 minutes respectively and not a smidge of a chance.

If you want to go on minutes he's had about 200 minutes and in that time we've scored sorry, yes, 5 goals. Him assisting 2. He also should've had 2 penalties against Boro.
Quite the impact if you ask me. Feel free to disagree but you're wrong and the management clearly think so too.
Click to expand...

Are we ignoring the games when he didn't do anything then? That's cherry picking to suit your argument.

2 assists in 200 mins. Pretty good. He looks good. But early days. Conor Sammon scored twice in his first 5 games.

As I said in response to Silent, management will not use him long term if he doesn't score. They dropped Hanson and Done for that and they dropped Clarke for that.
 
wizadry said:
No hatred from me mate, we’ll wait and see and I’m sure I’ll be able to produce a post or two at the seasons end.

I didn’t want us to sign him as I thought he was shit before he came here but he’s had a decent start, no more no less, let’s see how it pans out from here on in.

I will state beyond doubt that I want the Blades to do very well indeed as I’m sure you know and if he contributes then he contributes but I won’t be told by anyone on here what’s necessary or not when it isn’t hatred, it’s more a realistic post on someone who’s played a handful of minutes in the context of things.

Anyone would think we were shit before he came in from some of the things you read on here, I won’t listen or read that bollocks or be influenced by the agenda some like to drive on social media.
Click to expand...
For the record, I think he's very good at what he's been brought in for and has an important role to play during the final run in.
All this bollocks about his previous is irrelevant.
Some of the best players I ever played with had criminal records as long as my arm, I never let it affect my on field relationship with them.
And does it really matter who scores goals as long as we score them?
 
I really don’t care what he does for us, I’ll never celebrate a goal he scores whilst wearing a blades shirt & his loan can’t end soon enough for me. Other than that, more power to his elbow. :)
 
LSF said:
For the record, I think he's very good at what he's been brought in for and has an important role to play during the final run in.
All this bollocks about his previous is irrelevant.
Some of the best players I ever played with had criminal records as long as my arm, I never let it affect my on field relationship with them.
And does it really matter who scores goals as long as we score them?
Click to expand...
I can’t disagree with anything there really and as I say we’ll wait and see what he produces in more than a handful of minutes.

It doesn’t matter who scores in the grand scheme of things aslong as we win games but as Rev quite rightly points out, as a striker he could do with scoring as Wilder drops players a lot of the time for not scoring goals.

As I said earlier on though, a decent start but let’s not get ahead of ourselves just yet. You’ll hear more from me on this subject if he proves to be a good addition in a month or so’s time, that you have my word LSF.
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom